Just polished my 8 month old 1880's Chester, here's the result:
The pictures don't do them justice, but they look like a new pair of shoes again despite having considerable wear over the 8 months.
A pair of half-brogue 1880s have just been delivered on the capital last ('Strand' I think), courtesy of Herring (including a free shoe tree with the Ask Andy promotion). Second to none customer service from Herring yet again. Far prefer that last to the AE.
How much did you pay for the resoling? Sounds good though, 10 years for shoes at this price point can't be argued with!