• Hi, I am the owner and main administrator of Styleforum. If you find the forum useful and fun, please help support it by buying through the posted links on the forum. Our main, very popular sales thread, where the latest and best sales are listed, are posted HERE

    Purchases made through some of our links earns a commission for the forum and allows us to do the work of maintaining and improving it. Finally, thanks for being a part of this community. We realize that there are many choices today on the internet, and we have all of you to thank for making Styleforum the foremost destination for discussions of menswear.
  • This site contains affiliate links for which Styleforum may be compensated.
  • We would like to welcome House of Huntington as an official Affiliate Vendor. Shop past season Drake's, Nigel Cabourn, Private White V.C. and other menswear luxury brands at exceptional prices below retail. Please visit the Houise of Huntington thread and welcome them to the forum.

  • STYLE. COMMUNITY. GREAT CLOTHING.

    Bored of counting likes on social networks? At Styleforum, you’ll find rousing discussions that go beyond strings of emojis.

    Click Here to join Styleforum's thousands of style enthusiasts today!

    Styleforum is supported in part by commission earning affiliate links sitewide. Please support us by using them. You may learn more here.

venividivicibj

Stylish Dinosaur
Joined
Apr 9, 2013
Messages
22,783
Reaction score
18,247
I'm looking to buy two shoes, a NST, and a shortwing or partialy brogued cap toe derby, and am deciding between C&J and Carmina (not having owned either)

Does one offer a significant advantage in price or quality? (Or on the same note, does one have more much more sleek lasts than the other?)
 

eluther

Senior Member
Joined
Apr 10, 2011
Messages
671
Reaction score
1,038
Both Crockett & Jones's lasts I've tried on, the 360 and the 348, both have elongated toe boxes, which weren't amazing.

Both Carmina lasts I've tried on, the Inca and the Rain, had handsome toe boxes that I much preferred.

That being said, my Crockett & Jones are of a superlative quality, while the construction of the Carminas felt amazing, but not quite to the same standard.
 

venividivicibj

Stylish Dinosaur
Joined
Apr 9, 2013
Messages
22,783
Reaction score
18,247
Are the prices similar?

(And are your C&Js hand grade or bench?)
 

Gerry Nelson

Distinguished Member
Joined
Oct 16, 2011
Messages
7,970
Reaction score
35,328
360 is handgrade, 348 is benchgrade. I actually think that Carmina is better finished with more elegant lasts than Crockett.

I don't think C&J has a NST. The Onslow is close but not a split toe. Carmina has one on the Soller last and one on the Queen.

Price-wise, I think Carmina from their website is about the same as Crockett and Jones benchgrade.

Both have sleek lasts, the question is more about what the shape of your feet is like. First, find lasts that suit your foot and worry about the aesthetics.
 

dddrees

Distinguished Member
Joined
Aug 27, 2012
Messages
9,323
Reaction score
1,605
I would also include Alfred Sargent in this comparison. The reason I would do so is because the price of these three can be very close depending where you buy them from and whether you get them on sale or not. The reason I have examples of each of these brands has more to do with the design of a particular shoe more than the actual price or whether one brand is better than the other. All three of these brands make a real nice shoes.

If I were you, I would take a gander at the various appreciation threads for these brands as much has been said about the various strengths and or weaknesses of these brands.

I must say, I have yet to make a mistake when buying from either one of these brands.
 

jrd617

Stylish Dinosaur
Joined
Jul 15, 2009
Messages
15,291
Reaction score
2,660

I don't think C&J has a NST. The Onslow is close but not a split toe. Carmina has one on the Soller last and one on the Queen.


They make a number of split toe bluchers and monks for Brooks Brothers and Ben Silver. I think they are exclusives
 
Last edited:

Ilovelobbs

Senior Member
Joined
Feb 25, 2013
Messages
687
Reaction score
75
Quote:
You can't go wrong with Crockett's or Carmina - both exceptional value.... The finishing of the Carmina's are very good. Leather & build quality very good... Crockett's has the egde with me due to their 337, 350; 360; 351; 348 and 358 Last...
 

cazone

Active Member
Joined
Aug 7, 2013
Messages
32
Reaction score
26


Hello!

may I add a question here?

I'm looking to for a pair of half brogues to add/replace a pair of C&J Westfield (last 341).

Crockett, as usual or maybe somewhere else (Carmina) ?

Maybe something in between the Audley (last 337) and the Lonsdale (last 363).
I really like the Audley, rediscovered them recently through a fabulous fair of Bellegrave that I saw on instagram.
And I love the Lonsdale !
The last is my favorite (except the six holes ... )

So C&J, have the Barrington 2 (last 363) and the Bellegrave (last 337).
Both are nice shoes.

Otherwise a pair of Carminas would be cool!
But I just don't understand their different last ...

Maybe someone could help me out here.


Merci d'avance
c*
 

cazone

Active Member
Joined
Aug 7, 2013
Messages
32
Reaction score
26
comparing C&J vs Carmina on the basis of lasts alone is strange to me
look at the leather quality, leather type, the soles, the colors available, quality feedback, etc, etc

Sure.
I know C&J quite well and also had a look on Carminas.
The leather quality, leather type, between the C&J main line and Carmina is close.
General quality too.

My only concern is the last.
I just don't understand the different lasts in Carminas product range.
And I don't understand how they compare to the C&J lasts that I know (and fit me) very well.

I need some advice like:
C&J last 337 = Carmina ...
C&J last 341 = close to ...
C&J last 363 = etc ...

c*

PS: I saw the Barrington 2 this WE.

A beautiful shoe!
 

Chowkin

Senior Member
Joined
Mar 8, 2012
Messages
899
Reaction score
308
comparing C&J vs Carmina on the basis of lasts alone is strange to me
look at the leather quality, leather type, the soles, the colors available, quality feedback, etc, etc
Wonder if Carminas have oak bark soles?
 

Petepan

Distinguished Member
Joined
Apr 27, 2012
Messages
1,604
Reaction score
492

Yes, JR soles are oak bark tanned.  Thanks a lot.  But would that be limited to just shell shoes?


Not sure. I have 2 pairs of shell and one calf, and the JR stamp is only found on one pair of shell and not on the other two. The wear rate as far as i can tell is the same.
 

AndrewJH

New Member
Joined
Oct 22, 2014
Messages
4
Reaction score
1
I'm looking at two brown suede cap toe shoes; one is the Carmina Simple Toe Cap (Simpson last), and the second is the C&J Hallam (348 last).

Does anyone have experience with these two, and fit differences?

Thanks.
 

Featured Sponsor

How important is full vs half canvas to you for heavier sport jackets?

  • Definitely full canvas only

    Votes: 55 35.5%
  • Half canvas is fine

    Votes: 60 38.7%
  • Really don't care

    Votes: 17 11.0%
  • Depends on fabric

    Votes: 27 17.4%
  • Depends on price

    Votes: 28 18.1%

Forum statistics

Threads
505,186
Messages
10,579,227
Members
223,895
Latest member
amylguardinfo
Top