It's in downtown Jersey City, so, out of your range probably, but it is considered one of the best in the tri-state area - Very much like the old-school shops in Manhattan. Honestly, when I walk in I feel like I'm gonna bump into John Gotti, or some other boss or Consigliere in one of the 5 families.
Seriously, he does such an amazing job. He is a bit pricy, and there is often a longer wait then you would get at another lesser shop - But very well worth it. The place offers such an old-world feel, and the people working there are a pleasure to talk to. I consider it an experience just walking into the place.
There is a website I believe going by the same name. It is also very well-reviewed on Yelp, so you can see for yourself.
Again, I realize it might be a bit far for you - which is why I consider myself very lucky to be within walking distance - but I would travel an even longer distance for a shop like this.