Ok gents, so after taking in the advice of each person and a bit here and there, these are my final 4. Personally I am leaning towards white shirt/wine color tie combination. My least favorite is the blue shirt/wine color tie combination. Its good, but in terms of where it stacks up to the others would be in last place from my own choice.
The shoes - I found a pair of kenneth cole reaction shoes on sale (last one on the shelf and exactly my size to the 0.5!) which is still a square toe shoe but is an improvement over the other pair. Not polished in the pics by the way so keep that in mind.
Tie - Both 100% silk ties with not much shine; darker blue than my previous tie and the length when tied and tightened is the tip of the tie is at the base of my belt buckle.
Shirts - 100% cotton slim fit, non-iron. Fitted white t-shirt under.
Suit - No alteration however I'm keen on getting the pants altered if any. The pics really make the length seem shoddy.
Onto the pics (point and shoot camera at not the best angle - so keep that in mind as well).
Only top button done ;)