or Connect
Styleforum › Forums › Men's Style › Classic Menswear › Florsheim vs. Allen Edmond
New Posts  All Forums:Forum Nav:

Florsheim vs. Allen Edmond

post #1 of 14
Thread Starter 

Florshein Edgar ($115) vs Allen Edmond Park Avenue ($345)

Which one is a better value? They look almost identical.

post #2 of 14
Thread Starter 

post #3 of 14

I would  think the quality difference would be what under  the surface not whats on the surface.  These two may look alike but they are not.

post #4 of 14

Have you seen either shoe in real life? The Edgar (if that's the Florsheim captoe they sell at Macy's and the like) is made out of cheap-looking leather on an ugly last. The PA isn't my favorite captoe (I don't like the proportions or the thick welt), but it doesn't scream "cheap" the way the Edgar does.

post #5 of 14
Florsheim Edgar (My Rating: 2 out of 5)
  • Made in India
  • Thin and stiff 'Box Calf' leather uppers
  • Leather sole.
  • Leather & synthetic insole


In terms of quality, they are but a shadow of the Florsheim shoes of yesteryear.
These shoes generally serve a temporary need for a man who almost never wears a suit or dresses up for anything but the occasional interview, wedding, etc. They basically appeal to someone who wants the 'cheapest option' to fulfill minimum dress requirements and is unconcerned about lesser materials or out-sourced labour. They are also an acceptable option for someone who hasn't the funds for something more substantial. Their redeeming value is that they will pass muster at almost any function that isn't exclusive. Basically, they are clean and presentable looking. They are better than Bostonian, but still remain in the lower tier of mens dress shoes, albeit not the lowest of the low.
Be prepared to have sweaty feet at the end of a day's wearing. Because of the use of synthetics for the insoles, your feet may be offered little to no breathability. Carry an extra pair of socks with you in a zip-locked sandwich bag, and use them half way into your day or event to feel refreshed.
Aside from the breathability issue, they should be comfortable enough.
Your strategy here is to a) move quickly when walking b) keep your feet under the table during an interview, and c) at social functions, don't stand near men wearing Park Avenues (or better), for if you do, you'll understand why when you see their better shoes. You may even experience a dream-like state where you are the Incredible Shrinking Man. Another strategy is to gravitate towards men wearing total crap on their feet so you look like a million dollars.


Allen Edmonds Park Avenue (My Rating: 3 1/2 out of 5)
  • Made in the United States Of America
  • Soft Calfskin Vegetable Tanned leather uppers
  • Leather sole (no steel shank = airport friendly)
  • Full leather insoles


Signifigantly more appealing visually, the Park Avenue is an instantaneously comfortable shoe that requires no 'break-in' period. They easily look more elegant (as is possible with a 360 GoodYear Welt) than the Florsheim Edgar. You will experience immediate and lasting comfort with the Park Avenue (as you would with all Allen Edmonds shoes). The all-leather insole and liners offer excellent breathability for all day or night comfort. Suitable for all semi-formal occasions, exclusive or otherwise. Your feet will enjoy comfort every minute of your outing. The Park Avenues are among the entry level options within the higher end shoe range. They will age well and stand the test of time. They are fully recraftable, which further extends their lifespan to, with care and conservative wear, even a lifetime. A shoe of this caliber is considered an investment and should be among the mainstays of every mans wardrobe. If you can at least find a pair of Factory Seconds, they will be well worth the extra money over the Florsheims.
Polishing Tip: Sparingly apply dark Marine Blue cream polish to the toebox only for a dynamic 'blacker-than-black' contrast effect.
post #6 of 14
Quote:
Originally Posted by Man Of Lint View Post

Florsheim Edgar (My Rating: 2 out of 5)
  • Made in India
  • Thin and stiff 'Box Calf' leather uppers
  • Leather sole.
  • Leather & synthetic insole


In terms of quality, they are but a shadow of the Florsheim shoes of yesteryear.
These shoes generally serve a temporary need for a man who almost never wears a suit or dresses up for anything but the occasional interview, wedding, etc. They basically appeal to someone who wants the 'cheapest option' to fulfill minimum dress requirements and is unconcerned about lesser materials or out-sourced labour. They are also an acceptable option for someone who hasn't the funds for something more substantial. Their redeeming value is that they will pass muster at almost any function that isn't exclusive. Basically, they are clean and presentable looking. They are better than Bostonian, but still remain in the lower tier of mens dress shoes, albeit not the lowest of the low.
Be prepared to have sweaty feet at the end of a day's wearing. Because of the use of synthetics for the insoles, your feet may be offered little to no breathability. Carry an extra pair of socks with you in a zip-locked sandwich bag, and use them half way into your day or event to feel refreshed.
Aside from the breathability issue, they should be comfortable enough.
Your strategy here is to a) move quickly when walking b) keep your feet under the table during an interview, and c) at social functions, don't stand near men wearing Park Avenues (or better), for if you do, you'll understand why when you see their better shoes. You may even experience a dream-like state where you are the Incredible Shrinking Man. Another strategy is to gravitate towards men wearing total crap on their feet so you look like a million dollars.


Allen Edmonds Park Avenue (My Rating: 3 1/2 out of 5)
  • Made in the United States Of America
  • Soft Calfskin Vegetable Tanned leather uppers
  • Leather sole (no steel shank = airport friendly)
  • Full leather insoles


Signifigantly more appealing visually, the Park Avenue is an instantaneously comfortable shoe that requires no 'break-in' period. They easily look more elegant (as is possible with a 360 GoodYear Welt) than the Florsheim Edgar. You will experience immediate and lasting comfort with the Park Avenue (as you would with all Allen Edmonds shoes). The all-leather insole and liners offer excellent breathability for all day or night comfort. Suitable for all semi-formal occasions, exclusive or otherwise. Your feet will enjoy comfort every minute of your outing. The Park Avenues are among the entry level options within the higher end shoe range. They will age well and stand the test of time. They are fully recraftable, which further extends their lifespan to, with care and conservative wear, even a lifetime. A shoe of this caliber is considered an investment and should be among the mainstays of every mans wardrobe. If you can at least find a pair of Factory Seconds, they will be well worth the extra money over the Florsheims.
Polishing Tip: Sparingly apply Marine Blue cream polish to the toebox only for a dynamic 'blacker-than-black' contrast effect.

In my experience, with little or no breathing, your feet will be just cold, dry, cracked and so on and so forth in the winter as they will be sweaty in the summer.
post #7 of 14
Quote:
Originally Posted by OxxfordSJLINY View Post

In my experience, with little or no breathing, your feet will be just cold, dry, cracked and so on and so forth in the winter as they will be sweaty in the summer.

For what its worth, I suffer from cracked skin on my feet and fingers in winter as well. It is attributed to dehydration. I simply don't drink enough water in winter. You may want to try applying a moisturizing lotion to your feet and hands to aid in preventing the cracks. Also, use one of those scrapers on the thickly callused skin areas whilst taking a shower. Thinner skin that is lotioned, at least in my experience, will be more flexible and be less prone to cracking than thicker skin. Hope this helps someone somewhere.
post #8 of 14

My understanding is some time ago a foreigin business bought the company and brought the production over to south east asia to take advantage of cheap labor.  Problem here is the end result was not quite up to standards.  Recently the original family that once owned the company has bought back the company and is in the process of fixing the quality problem.  As a consequence some of the Floorshiems are good but you go to know which ones.  You really got to know what you are talking about.


Edited by jbcohen - 5/23/13 at 4:52am
post #9 of 14
Correcting my earlier post..
Quote:

WEYCO Group, Inc. (NASDAQ: WEYS), designs and markets quality and innovative footwear for men, women and children under a portfolio of well-recognized brand names including; Florsheim, Nunn Bush, Stacy Adams, BOGS, Rafters and Umi. The company's products can be found in leading footwear, department, and specialty stores worldwide. Weyco Group also operates Florsheim concept stores in the United States and Australia, as well as in a variety of international markets.
http://www.weycogroup.com/investor.html
Quote:

In 2002, the company was repurchased by members of the founding family. Thomas W. Florsheim, Jr. and John W. Florsheim of Weyco Group, based in Glendale, Wisconsin, repurchased the brand for $47 million from rival Florsheim Group, according to the Wall Street Journal.
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Florsheim_Shoes
Quote:

Edited by MyOtherLife - 5/22/13 at 6:13am
post #10 of 14
Quote:
Originally Posted by jbcohen View Post

My understanding is some time ago a foreigin business bought hte company and brought the production over to south east asia to take advantage of cheap labor.  Problem here is the end result was not quite up to standards.  

The India chapter began in 1996. Quality was maintained for 2 years before the slide. In recent years, select models (example- Veblen, Duckie Brown line, etc.) are indicators of efforts to improve quality and I for one am very happy about this.
post #11 of 14
At clearance prices, I consider Florsheim LWBs to be of good value. I picked up a pair of new Veblens for $75 at STP and while I got my shell cordovan Duckie Browns pre-owned at significant cost savings, the original owner got them from GILT for only $250.

To be clear, one need not look too carefully to see that skill of the craftsmen in India do not match those in America ... the finishing and assembly of AE shoes are much better.
post #12 of 14
Quote:
Originally Posted by Man Of Lint View Post

For what its worth, I suffer from cracked skin on my feet and fingers in winter as well. It is attributed to dehydration. I simply don't drink enough water in winter. You may want to try applying a moisturizing lotion to your feet and hands to aid in preventing the cracks. Also, use one of those scrapers on the thickly callused skin areas whilst taking a shower. Thinner skin that is lotioned, at least in my experience, will be more flexible and be less prone to cracking than thicker skin. Hope this helps someone somewhere.

Yes, skin moisturizer will absolutely keep anybody's feet from having cracked skin in the winter. However, my feet will still be cold and uncomfortable (and occasionally or sore) from wearing shoes with synthetic (specifically, leatherette or vinyl insoles) in the winter.
post #13 of 14

Ok so they have made some quality improvements here and there however its not uniform for all the company products.  I prefer dealing with companies were I buy anything they make and its great.

post #14 of 14
Quote:
Originally Posted by OxxfordSJLINY View Post

Yes, skin moisturizer will absolutely keep anybody's feet from having cracked skin in the winter. However, my feet will still be cold and uncomfortable (and occasionally or sore) from wearing shoes with synthetic (specifically, leatherette or vinyl insoles) in the winter.

I agree wholeheartedly. Natural materials over synthetics at all times.

Quote:
Originally Posted by jbcohen View Post

Ok so they have made some quality improvements here and there however its not uniform for all the company products.  I prefer dealing with companies were I buy anything they make and its great.

Agreed, yet, it is good to know that Florsheim is making a good effort to, as much as is economically feasible for them, reach back to their glory days and offer some decent quality models within a very reasonable price..
New Posts  All Forums:Forum Nav:
  Return Home
  Back to Forum: Classic Menswear
Styleforum › Forums › Men's Style › Classic Menswear › Florsheim vs. Allen Edmond