I'm about the same build as you, wider set shoulders. I wear a large in villains and they fit perfect, slightly on the slim side. Saw ppl on here saying go with your villain size for the intended fit so I actually went with a large. Anyways guess you'll get to try both haha so let me know how that goes cause I'm kinda worried too now
Yeah, I got some decently wide shoulders as well (blame the gym lol). Never owned a Villain so definitely don't know how these compare to fit. Will let you know how things pan out.