I use this:
Blends perfectly with Old Spice "Classic Scent" cologne (or "classic scent" aftershave), also seems to go perfect well with Banana Republic's "Slate" cologne.
Other colognes in my collection that don't clash;
- Pinaud Clubman
- Bay Rum aftershave/cologne (homemade via tweaked recipe form "Art of Manliness" )
- Polo (original scent)
Because everyone’s natural smell is different, colognes and aftershaves will react differently to each individual. It is impossible to say that what works well for me will work well for others. I believe that a person should choose a fragrance that will subtly enhance their own natural scent, and only be detectable when someone is within hugging/kissing range.
If you cannot find a scented antiperspirant that doesn't clash with your cologne(s) of choice, then you could look into the unscented clinic antiperspirants.