Originally Posted by scurvyfreedman
I'm only about halfway through the thread, but have you considered the one-shirt for business and one-shirt for casual? They can even be the same fabric, but the business would be spread collar and single cuff and the casual would be BD and barrel cuff. I realize this is two-shirt, but aren't business and casual two completely different environments where there is not one perfect shirt that meets both needs, but there is one perfect shirt for each?
I will no doubt need a buttondown solution sooner or later, as my MTM Brooks OCBDs will need replacement and never had the perfect roll. However, I'm in no dire need right now, so I'd be happy if this batch of OneShirt is entirely business-leaning.
If I have them them done with buttondown collars (and barrel cuffs), I'll still wear them for business. A spread collar would be more ideal perhaps, but I hold to the principle that a buttondown is always fine for business wear in America.