RIP: Need help replacing this blue $70 JCrew casual dress shirt.

My $70 JCrew shirt has been a workhorse for the last 5 years. This is a casual shirt usually displayed untucked with jeans or cords. I also wore it under sweaters and cardigans. I wore it under sport jackets. The collar was small and soft. Since it wasn't a button down collar, it was just dressy enough to wear a casual knit tie, but it was too casual for dress pants and formal ties. Is there a name for this style of shirt?

One of the best fitting OTR shirts I've ever bought. It needed no alterations for a 7-8in drop. The torso was very slim and tapered. The sleeves were the same. It was short, and could be worn untucked.

The elbows finally both disintegrated. I need a replacement, as this shirt is a staple of my wardrobe. Can anyone help me find a replacement?

Here is a photo of the actual shirt.
http://i47.tinypic.com/t0goox.jpg

This is close, but it has buttons on the collar.
http://tinyurl.com/byy9dem

The azure colored one here is too denim in color, but has the correct collar.
This looks a little too casual to dress up. Why?
http://tinyurl.com/cnk9aja

Ivar, yes the collar is unlined. Similar to ODCB, but without the button.
Suggesting to go MTM is unnecessary, as it's way too casual to go MTM.
The cloth is a hybrid between a thicker casual cotton and a more sheer dress cloth.
This is what made the shirt so damn versatile. You could dress it up or down.

Mp, I can't find a replacement at JCrew. That's why I started this thread.
I might just need to settle for the button down collar, which I HATE wearing with a tie.

To dress it up, it can be worn with a sport coat or with a knit tie.
To dress it down, it can be worn untucked with jeans.

My budget is about $70 for an unlined cotton RTW shirt.
Edited by Reevolving - 3/4/13 at 7:06am