Definitely snug but not uncomfortably so after the first or second wear. It breaks in to be just about perfect. I only have one shoe in Forest and it definitely fits different (neither too small nor too large) but if I sized up I'd be swimming in it.
^^ Fellas, please. I enjoy a good flaming battle as much as the next guy but this is not the place.
Having had my own run in with the self appointed arbiter of taste that Aldenwear thinks he is, I can advise that this is really a path to stay away from. And Leaves, it's a tradition here to get extra feisty as the holidays approach!