I was using the same photo and the above list when I suggested EG mink
Well we're both okay with #5 then - but it depends on whether Carmina has a close match to that shade - any darker and I'd pass. I have the boot below - do not want to replicate:
In fact, if we don't get the minimum for a suede option quickly I'll just take advantage of the Bonafe MTO special and go that route to scratch my suede boot itch.
Would prefer something like 4 or 5 to 3 but it sounds like we're looking for something similar.