I wonder if these guys are wearing kamakura shirts..
I like the fabric and fit, but I agree about the collar as it is much too short.
I wear a 15.75/35 in the NY Slim Fit and the sleeve placket measures out at just over six inches. The cuff is about 2 7/8 inches on top of that.
A few weeks back I was able to stop into the NY store and even more than the selection of shirts I was really impressed by their tie selection. Knits, grenadine, wool. Some really great stuff.
Also just got these in the mail:
Warning: Spoiler! (Click to show)
FWIW - the medium Vintage Ivy Chambray fits almost exactly like the NY Slim I usually wear.
I wear a 15.75 as well, and the medium vintage shirt was considerably smaller in the chest and the shoulders for me. Even tried on both shirts after each other, and noticed a remarkable difference.
That's odd. I just measured my medium chambray and one of my oxfords and the P2P on both was 22". Strange.