or Connect
Styleforum › Forums › Men's Style › Classic Menswear › Best bespoke commission ever? I think so. *** PICTURES ADDED FOR THOSE LACKING IMAGINATION
New Posts  All Forums:Forum Nav:

Best bespoke commission ever? I think so. *** PICTURES ADDED FOR THOSE LACKING IMAGINATION - Page 10

post #136 of 436
Quote:
Originally Posted by hendrix View Post


Disagree.

That thing looks like a shitty military surplus coat and only looks reasonable because of good photography and (presumably) a perfectly proportioned model.

 

That's because its made from the same pattern block, and same cloth as the original great coats made for the British armed forces.

 

I made that clear in my post.

 

It is the original style from which the others are derived. Hence it is instructive.

post #137 of 436
Thread Starter 
Okay, here's the porn.

The coat is fully lined with the plaid cashmere, but the typical silk lining is laid over the shoulders and lines the sleeves (not shown).

foo_overcoatdetail_1_small_zps88b78fea.jpg

This loop can be used to fasten the fronts together so they don't flap around. As you can tell from the other button, you can also fasten it back to its own side if you want to keep it out of the way.

foo_overcoatdetail_2_small_zps00f98576.jpg

I can find only one interior pocket. Due to the horizontally oriented entry, I was worried it wouldn't be the right shape or size for my wallet. However, the pocket curves downward into a vertical rectangle, so the wallet slips in very easily. Strikes me as an unusual solution, but I'm no expert on overcoat construction.

foo_overcoatdetail_3_small_zpsffa29f79.jpg

foo_overcoatdetail_4_small_zps6c9f8b43.jpg

foo_overcoatdetail_5_small_zpsa628086f.jpg

foo_overcoatdetail_6_small_zps6027ad6f.jpg

You have to look carefully, but you can see that the lining is fully hand-stitched to the coat. I have to admit, I was at first surprised to hear how much they charge for an overcoat. It is more than a suit. I was imagining it shouldn't cost more than making a really long odd jacket. However, after seeing all the extra detail work that must go into this sort of thing, I totally understand. If nothing else, it must be real pain to hand-stitch so much thick and heavy cloth.

foo_overcoatdetail_7_small.jpg

The somewhat vestigial breast pocket. If I could have had it my way, it wouldn't exist. I don't like that it is so close to the top button.

foo_overcoatdetail_8_small_zpsbb191a86.jpg

The controversially chunky martingale. For what it's worth, I asked for it this wide--to the centimeter.

foo_overcoatdetail_9_small_zps6b591e33.jpg

The pleated rear opening. Very cool. The opening is stitched shut right where the belt ends.

foo_overcoatdetail_10_small_zpscce34a29.jpg

My eight centimeter cuffs. I asked for ten, but was vetoed. It turned out that everything is eight centimeters wide: the pocket flaps, the martingale belt, and the cuffs.

foo_overcoatdetail_11_small_zpscff09736.jpg

For those who missed them earlier, the envelope-style hip pockets. Or mailbox, mail-slot, whatever. I think an investigation into the various forms of such pockets would make for an interesting future (near future?) discussion. Apparently these are globally atypical, but a known form in Naples (see the last few pages).

My earlier guess that such pockets are unheard of in Naples is clearly wrong.
Warning: Spoiler! (Click to show)
funnypocket1_small_zpsc3733dc0.jpg

funnypocket2_small_zps27f8aef5.jpg

funnypocket3_small_zps15d9d01f.jpg

funnypocket4_small_zps3692047d.jpg
post #138 of 436
It's nice to be able to get a sense of the details and cloth, Foo. Thanks for taking those shots.

I've had overcoats with both a basic welted pocket and the kind yours has, and much prefer the latter. FME, the first has a higher risk of losing wallets and contents. Sometimes it gets hot, and you take off your coat, then drape it over your arm, but that position makes it easy for things to fall out without your knowing. It happened to me once in an airport, but luckily I had already arrived at my destination.
post #139 of 436
Fantastic details and fabric.

Lol @ the "casual" appearance of the green wallet.
post #140 of 436

Thanks, foo - appreciate the detail shots (the Hermes in the wild!).

 

It seems that all Italian tailors charge more for an overcoat relative to a suit (Mina also charges 30% more). Must have something to do with the handstitching involved, as the SR crew charge the same price as a suit.

post #141 of 436
Thread Starter 
Quote:
Originally Posted by Lovelace View Post

It is the original style from which the others are derived. Hence it is instructive.

It certainly is. However, you really couldn't wear something like that without looking (or feeling) like you belong on a period movie set. I tried hard to make sure my coat didn't come across that way. As conflicted as I am about the breast pocket, it certainly does help civilian-ize.
Quote:
Originally Posted by Ich_Dien View Post

Lol @ the "casual" appearance of the green wallet.

Recurring characters are typical in good stories. smile.gif
post #142 of 436
Thank you for following up with interior shots. The inside pocket is typical standard issue on a topcoat and a place to carry gloves. We put a large patch pocket on the lower interior to store a scarf, wanted to know if they do the same.

Looks like the coat is lined with the cashmere plaid throughout and the brown lining overlaying the plaid.

Agree about the breast welt. Don't think it blends with the feeling of the garment or is practical with the size and placement of the lapels. Would put one on a dressier coat but not here.

It is also standard to standardize the width of pocket flaps, belt, cuffs for continuity.

Are the pleats on the back sewn thru by the buttons to hold them in place or are they loose?
post #143 of 436
Here's something similar from a little further north.



I think the proportions of the details are considerably more tasteful in this example.

But it was genius doing it in tweed. Makes it much more versatile, as you said.
post #144 of 436
Thread Starter 
Quote:
Originally Posted by Despos View Post

We put a large patch pocket on the lower interior to store a scarf, wanted to know if they do the same.

I totally should have asked for that. Sounds awesome.
Quote:
Originally Posted by Despos View Post

Looks like the coat is lined with the cashmere plaid throughout and the brown lining overlaying the plaid.

Yes.
Quote:
Originally Posted by Despos View Post

Are the pleats on the back sewn thru by the buttons to hold them in place or are they loose?

I'm not sure what you mean. If you unbutton the buttons, the two sides come fully apart.
post #145 of 436
Thread Starter 
Quote:
Originally Posted by Cantabrigian View Post

I think the proportions of the details are considerably more tasteful in this example.

It's very nice, but the detailing is too gentile for me.
post #146 of 436
Quote:
I'm not sure what you mean. If you unbutton the buttons, the two sides come fully apart.

There are two vertical pleats extending above and below the waist on each side of the center back seam. Are they tacked thru in any way to hold them in place or are they loose and only held in by the tension of the belt closure? Did I explain well?
post #147 of 436
Quote:
Originally Posted by Lovelace View Post

That's because its made from the same pattern block, and same cloth as the original great coats made for the British armed forces.

I made that clear in my post.

It is the original style from which the others are derived. Hence it is instructive.

Yup, I'm not attacking your post, it is indeed instructive and informative. I just didn't understand the comment that "this looks better than the bespoke one". It was just a silly comment to make.
post #148 of 436
That is fantastic, thanks for the detail shots.

Hope you got to break that thing in this morning... Bet that warm cashmere lining was appreciated.
post #149 of 436
Quote:
Originally Posted by Despos View Post

We put a large patch pocket on the lower interior to store a scarf, wanted to know if they do the same.

Another good idea would be a few hooks or loops of fabric that can hold the scarf in , instead of stuffing it in to a pocket, it could possibly lay flat in the interior of the coat securely.
post #150 of 436
Thread Starter 
Quote:
Originally Posted by Despos View Post

There are two vertical pleats extending above and below the waist on each side of the center back seam. Are they tacked thru in any way to hold them in place or are they loose and only held in by the tension of the belt closure? Did I explain well?

Ah, gotcha. Yes, they are tacked right underneath the belt.
New Posts  All Forums:Forum Nav:
  Return Home
  Back to Forum: Classic Menswear
Styleforum › Forums › Men's Style › Classic Menswear › Best bespoke commission ever? I think so. *** PICTURES ADDED FOR THOSE LACKING IMAGINATION