What is a better buy in terms of over quality, style, and appeal? Would love to see pictures if anyone owns either shoe, thanks!
Allen Edmonds McAllister Merlot?
Or To boot Windsor in Bordo?
I would also be one of those with the McAllister in Walnut. For burgundy I went with the Cambridge in #8 shell which is basically the shell version of the McAllister. It is one of my favorite shoes and sees a good amount of use. I highly recommend the Cambridge instead for burgundy. Although there is nothing wrong with the calf McAllister either.
Cambridge last spring: