or Connect
Styleforum › Forums › Men's Style › Classic Menswear › Official Wedding Attire Question/Answer/Picture Thread
New Posts  All Forums:Forum Nav:

Official Wedding Attire Question/Answer/Picture Thread - Page 30

post #436 of 2074
So, is the knot you have in the pic only a Half-Windsor? It looks very good...you can try a Full...but the Half looks like it is spot-on.

My God..where are you that you can't find a shirt with French cuffs? You can get that at Macy's or Kohls!
post #437 of 2074
Quote:
Originally Posted by MrDaniels View Post

So, is the knot you have in the pic only a Half-Windsor? It looks very good...you can try a Full...but the Half looks like it is spot-on.

My God..where are you that you can't find a shirt with French cuffs? You can get that at Macy's or Kohls!


It was actually my first attempt at a four in a hand knot shog[1].gif I'll give both a proper half and full windsor a try when I get home (those two I know how to tie haha).

 

I'm in Montreal but the main problem is the combination of slim fit and long arms. If I settled for regular fit it would have been a bit easier to find, but even with darts regular fit would have to be chopped on the sides by a tailor to somewhat fit my body shape.

 

That said, Montreal is one of the least fashion friendly cities for above average height or above average taste/standards. Which I have both :P.

post #438 of 2074
Please stick to four in hand. If you must, a half Windsor. Full Windsor is just a terrible, terrible, awful knot.
post #439 of 2074
Quote:
Originally Posted by Newcomer View Post

Please stick to four in hand. If you must, a half Windsor. Full Windsor is just a terrible, terrible, awful knot.

This.
post #440 of 2074
Quote:
Originally Posted by Newcomer View Post

A little bit of patina, but a whole lot of character.

Whaddya mean "but"? Patina IS character. biggrin.gif
Quote:
Originally Posted by pinkformen View Post

Thanks! Unfortunately I'm really running dry on funds frown.gif. I just picked up a Boss shirt for 220$. It fit like a glove right off the rack smile.gif

Good god, you can have custom shirts made for half that! Most of your money just went to the label.

Quote:
Originally Posted by Newcomer View Post

Please stick to four in hand. If you must, a half Windsor. Full Windsor is just a terrible, terrible, awful knot.

+1!
post #441 of 2074
Ha yeah my writing from my phone is terrible. I meant they got a little scuffed up, but that is just patina and character smile.gif
post #442 of 2074
Quote:
Originally Posted by pinkformen View Post


It was actually my first attempt at a four in a hand knot shog%5B1%5D.gifI'll give both a proper half and full windsor a try when I get home (those two I know how to tie haha).


I suspect you have your names confused...there is no way the knot in that pic is a four-in-hand.
post #443 of 2074
Quote:
Originally Posted by becnal View Post

Good god, you can have custom shirts made for half that! Most of your money just went to the label.
 

Yup, I know that but it fit without any alterations and in the time constraint (needed for tomorrow) it saved my butt. I'm still searching for a local tailor that can do shirts in the 100$ range though.

 

So far the cheapest and quality custom shirts are 300$ a piece (if I order three). I may go for it when I'm in Tokyo again next year.

Quote:
Originally Posted by MrDaniels View Post


I suspect you have your names confused...there is no way the knot in that pic is a four-in-hand.

I really wish I did. shog[1].gifshog[1].gifshog[1].gif I screwed up following this video https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=RitsFlQDL3g

 

Maybe it was my teenage muscle memory coming back wanting to do a full windsor? lol

Quote:
Originally Posted by Newcomer View Post

Please stick to four in hand. If you must, a half Windsor. Full Windsor is just a terrible, terrible, awful knot.

 

It seems like everyone is on board with this so will do!

post #444 of 2074
Full Windsor is not inherently terrible...it just has to be in proportion with the collar and the wearer's face/ neck/ head...and not tied with too thick/ wide of a knot-but there are a lot of guys who do not make a good choice and going around looking like a particularly stinky douchebag. For my money, a Half Winsdor is a great knot...especially with a spread collar on a formal occasion.
post #445 of 2074
Quote:
Originally Posted by MrDaniels View Post

Full Windsor is not inherently terrible...it just has to be in proportion with the collar and the wearer's face/ neck/ head...and not tied with too thick/ wide of a knot-but there are a lot of guys who do not make a good choice and going around looking like a particularly stinky douchebag. For my money, a Half Winsdor is a great knot...especially with a spread collar on a formal occasion.

 

Agreed!  I don't know where all this windsor hate is coming from!  It depends on the collar, the jacket, and many other factors what knot is appropriate.  Are these folks honestly suggesting that a four in hand knot could look good with a full spread collar?  I'm wearing a spread collar and full windsor at my wedding; a four in hand never even crossed my mind, especially as I'm wearing a morning coat.  In general, depending on the dimensions of the tie, I tie either a Prince Albert, or a half windsor.  I tie a full windsor in certain ties for more formal occasions.

 

I think the half windsor in the pic above is spot on.  A four-in-hand with that collar will probably make the whole neck area look far too empty.

post #446 of 2074
Most full Windsors are giant, hideous knots. A big part of the appeal of a FIH is that bit of asymmetry. Granted it might not work on a cutaway collar, but aside from that, it works with just about everything. I never tie anything else.

post #447 of 2074
I have seen a lot of men in formal and business occasions wear a spread collar with a tiny knot...it never looks good.
post #448 of 2074
I don't know what kind of ties you guys have that are tying tiny knots with a FIH. I never have any problems with it. It's usually the perfect size. If it's too small, tie a double FIH. Or buy a tie wider than 2".
post #449 of 2074
Quote:
Originally Posted by aravenel View Post

Most full Windsors are giant, hideous knots. A big part of the appeal of a FIH is that bit of asymmetry. Granted it might not work on a cutaway collar, but aside from that, it works with just about everything. I never tie anything else.


Well, that one is clearly too big. I think the guy wearing it is on the shorter side. There is no single knot that is going to work with every guy, every collar and every situation. Same with lapels.
post #450 of 2074
Thread Starter 
Fwiw, the duke himself never tied a Windsor knot. The knot was invented in order imitate the thick knots that he could create because his ties were made of heavy silks with thick wool interlinings. If you like thicker knots, get thicker ties. Then tie them FiH.
New Posts  All Forums:Forum Nav:
  Return Home
  Back to Forum: Classic Menswear
Styleforum › Forums › Men's Style › Classic Menswear › Official Wedding Attire Question/Answer/Picture Thread