17.5" p2p...damn that's small.
Hey Shingles, I saw the Andover at MAC in SF and liked it, although it's definitely cut a little bit differently than the winter version (but this is probably to be expected).
I'm typically a medium in most jackets and thought that this one felt a little bit tight up top - the arm holes were higher/more restrictive than I would have liked. This was also kind of strange because I thought the body of the jacket felt almost disproportionately loose in comparison. It's hard to describe but something felt a little bit off. Some of this might have had to do with the fabric. I saw tried it in cavalry twill, which is a lightweight yet robust material that doesn't seem to have a lot of give. This is a lot different from the wools/flannel that was used this winter, which allowed for a lot of mobility.
Despite all this, it's still a cool jacket, and probably is still my favorite jacket in the lineup. That said, I didn't buy it on the spot but I'm going to go back for a second look. I hope this helps. Let me know if you have any other questions and I'll try to help.
By the way, has anyone seen an ecru truman (size medium) still in stock anywhere outside of japan? I'm afraid I might've missed the boat on this one and I'm starting to kick myself.