As a guy that has very rarely ever worn fragrance, I think it's about time to purchase something to use for the right occasions. Creed seems to be the obvious choice, but I was curious to see if you had a favorite scent?
If you wear Creed, kindly get ITT
Original Santal and Aventus were the two that stood out to me, but before I even could know you would post Orange Spice as your #1, I knew I wanted something citrus-based. Unfortunately for me, I can get almost all of these except for Orange Spice and a couple others for the time being. Thanks for the input!
Aventus might be your safest bet since it smells extremely fresh (pineapple & blackberry?) and not too empowering, Original Santal smells extremely woody, but might be a little "Indian" smelling, although the woody smells very comfortable. To me, Green Irish Tweed smells fresh, but might be a little too sharp of a scent for my liking. Royal Oud makes you smell like an Arabian Prince, if that's what you're going for.
Windsor - Aventus layered w/ Riverside Drive - GIT layered w/ Escenttic Molecule 1 - Original Cologne
SMW was a blind buy for me and it smells way too metallic and sweet for my tastes. Definitely try it before buying, it is much more feminine than I anticipated.
Aventus is kind of like GIT for me. It's a great fragrance, but not sure if I'm convinced it's worth that much more than more common (and cheaper) scents.