Why are you here? This community is almost literally the antithesis of what you just said. We like to talk about clothes and style and yes, what tie looks best in a particular circumstance. Different people have different opinions, but if you don't care what you wear then why come to a place called "styleforum"?
To get other people's opinion on how to dress better. But if none if forthcoming, then I am going to make up my own opinion and not worry about it. Unless it is for something really important, like an important job interview and wearing the wrong clothing will cost me a job.
Like you said "different people have different opinions". If one person says tie A is better, tie B looks idiotic, and another person says the opposite, then I will make up my own mind who I think is right. I will not worry what other people think.