Real, whether they're worth paying for depends on how much is being asked, and the idea that it's bad for your feet is BS. Might be a little awkward at first as your feet break them in, but the same characteristics that allow leather to form to the first owners foot will allow it to form to yours. I've bought and worn used shoes many times without any trouble, good way to get nicer shoes for cheap. The soles look to be in okay shape, which probably means that they'll look a lot better with shoe trees and a polish.
Weird shoes though. I wouldn't buy that design for myself, even apart from my standard dislike of bit loafers. And the fact that the first photo makes them look like a size 14AAA.