I want inspired unique lunacy in any wardrobe I would raid, otherwise I may as well just order the stuff myself. I want to find items I'd never think about getting if left to my own devices, otherwise there's no point to it.
So I definitely agree with the vote above for PTWilliams, and would throw in RJman and (from what I can remember) stilmacher!
If you didn't join until August of 2011, you got less than 4 months of PG, certainly not enough to draw a complete opinion. His closet was well edited, but not meh.