AE Lasts- how do I know?

NO. Although at an Edmonds store, they are trained to help you obtain a good fit, in the final analysis, you put it on ( with the proper sock ), and walk around the store a bit. I always bring my own socks, casual- dress- etc. , for what I'm looking for.
But from the way I read your post, I'm getting the idea, that you are under the impression that you think, you can pick out a shoe design and get it in a certain last. Although you can order many of their shoes customized, as far as leather- color - sole- etc. , if it comes in a 5 last, it's a 5 last.
Go to a store and try on several different styles that come in different lasts and you will know how each last fits you. Myself, I take a 9 1/2 D (med ) in most shoes, but in some lasts ( styles ), I differ, in size or width. Foot size can also vary during the day ( swell ). I try to go shopping for shoes in late afternoon or early evening, to get the average amount of swelling.

 

Step 1:  Go to any Nordstrom or AE store and pick out a shoe you like.

Step 2:  Try that shoe on in the size the clerk recommends after sizing you.

Step 3:  If it fits, buy it.  If it does not, go back to step 1.

 

AE's are like women; you've got to try them on before you get the perfect fit. There's no magic formula. You've just got to get inside and see how it feels.

+1
Edited by md2010 - 10/4/12 at 8:04pm

wtf?

Do get the right fit you need not only find the right length as in case of Aldo shoes), but also the right width. Most retailers will only have the standard D-width in store (including Nordstrom). If possible go to an AE store where you can try different length - width combinations.