or Connect
Styleforum › Forums › Men's Style › Classic Menswear › Knee issues, hard leather soles, gel inserts, and sizing up 1/2
New Posts  All Forums:Forum Nav:

Knee issues, hard leather soles, gel inserts, and sizing up 1/2

post #1 of 7
Thread Starter 
I sometimes fear that wearing hard leather soles will eventually take a toll on my knees later in life. I raise this topic, again, because I recently added a certain leather soled shoe back into my Fall rotation. It is about 1/2 size too large. I happened to have a pair of gel heel inserts, and decided to put them in. Normally, I can't fit something like this into my shoes, but the 1/2 size disparity accommodated them perfectly. With the heel gels, I felt like I was walking on clouds. Only sneakers are more comfortable. They were almost as soft and bouncy as my J&M's which have a "bubble air gel" inner sole.

It made me think that I might size all future dress shoes 1/2 larger and add a heel insert gel. This seems to be a good compromise for now. Have any older members done this before resorting to ugly (but practical and comfortable) shoes to preserve your health and well-being? Has anyone had to give up leather soled shoes due to knee and joint pain later in life? Wearing thick rubber soled shoes (with thick plush inner soles) adds an entire component of shock absorption to complement your knee cartilage that is wholly absent from leather soled shoes. A heel gel is a step in that direction. Do you size up 1/2 or fit it into your current size?

For the delusional posters who insist that rock hard leathers soles are softer and more plush than sneakers or Ecco/Rockports, please save your internet insanity for another thread. In the real world, there is not a single orthopedist (or flight attendant) on the planet who will advise a person to wear leather soled shoes to reduce knee and joint pain. Women, who are obsessed with uncomfortable shoes from an early age know about this all too well. I'd like to hear from people in the real world, not people in their basements who never leave the house or go to a job. Thanks in advance.
Edited by Reevolving - 9/22/12 at 9:12am
post #2 of 7
I'm not old enough to give you long-term information but I know what you mean. I have some knee trouble in my late 20s and I'm not sure how hard leather soles have affected or will affect my knee problems. Having said that, there are a number of days that I end up walking 4-5 miles between offices and on/off public transport. In these cases, shoes such as Eccos are hard to beat. They won't get a lot of aesthetic love on this forum, but a rubber sole makes my feet and joints far less sore at the end of the day.

The shoes I love are worn when I'm in a single building a majority of the day. I don't have too many problems if I'm just standing/sitting in them.

I'm sorry I can't offer more information, just a bit of personal experience.
post #3 of 7
You need a shoe built for your foot. Try bespoke, the Alden Modified Last, the Carmina Forest Last, or Vass U Last.
post #4 of 7
I wear prescription orthotics and size up 1/2 to accommodate them. The only problems I've encountered come with extremely narrow lasts like Vass's F last, where the orthotics don't seem to fit in the shoes quite right.
post #5 of 7
Quote:
Originally Posted by vezatron View Post

You need a shoe built for your foot. Try bespoke, the Alden Modified Last, the Carmina Forest Last, or Vass U Last.

 

Do you have knee issues?  Or any bespoke experience?

post #6 of 7
Quote:
Originally Posted by Reevolving View Post

I sometimes fear that wearing hard leather soles will eventually take a toll on my knees later in life. I raise this topic, again, because I recently added a certain leather soled shoe back into my Fall rotation. It is about 1/2 size too large. I happened to have a pair of gel heel inserts, and decided to put them in. Normally, I can't fit something like this into my shoes, but the 1/2 size disparity accommodated them perfectly. With the heel gels, I felt like I was walking on clouds. Only sneakers are more comfortable. They were almost as soft and bouncy as my J&M's which have a "bubble air gel" inner sole.
It made me think that I might size all future dress shoes 1/2 larger and add a heel insert gel. This seems to be a good compromise for now. Have any older members done this before resorting to ugly (but practical and comfortable) shoes to preserve your health and well-being? Has anyone had to give up leather soled shoes due to knee and joint pain later in life? Wearing thick rubber soled shoes (with thick plush inner soles) adds an entire component of shock absorption to complement your knee cartilage that is wholly absent from leather soled shoes. A heel gel is a step in that direction. Do you size up 1/2 or fit it into your current size?
For the delusional posters who insist that rock hard leathers soles are softer and more plush than sneakers or Ecco/Rockports, please save your internet insanity for another thread. In the real world, there is not a single orthopedist (or flight attendant) on the planet who will advise a person to wear leather soled shoes to reduce knee and joint pain. Women, who are obsessed with uncomfortable shoes from an early age know about this all too well. I'd like to hear from people in the real world, not people in their basements who never leave the house or go to a job. Thanks in advance.

 

I got ankle issues and nothing's better than walking barefoot.  Cushioned shoes impedes my ankle stability and dress shoes do not.

post #7 of 7
nvm
Edited by dieworkwear - 9/22/12 at 12:39pm
New Posts  All Forums:Forum Nav:
  Return Home
  Back to Forum: Classic Menswear
Styleforum › Forums › Men's Style › Classic Menswear › Knee issues, hard leather soles, gel inserts, and sizing up 1/2