@ Kmarriner: not really sure what you did, but did you pile up the polish (i.e., layers on top of layers) without giving it a chance to cure? Also, base layers sometimes crack. If so, you'll have to strip it down and start afresh. The British military do this all the time to their boots (i.e., strip down, give them a good conditioning, brushing off the dirt, etc and polish up to a shine). It's easy to do, but if you're uncomfortable with this, just take your boots to a cobbler who can fix it up for you. @pseudonym: I don't know about today's Docs, but back in the day we'd mink oil them for winter and they were fine for all but those heavy snow/slushy mess days, and I'm talking about CDN winters. In NYC, you should be ok w/ heavy (i.e., full grain), oil and waxy leathers, having proper soles (non-slip thick rubber, as they are). Wear with proper socks so your toes don't get cold (i.e, thick and warm, like wool, etc., though there are also sheepskin and other thermal inserts on the market these days). Just be careful not to drag leather shoes/boots through salty-slushy messes, though--they can die of thirst. (Soaking cold feet isn't good, and the salt can dry out leather, etc.). That said, I think Doc has a winter line of boots, no? If you like the style, might want to check it out. EDIT: kmarriner, just thought I'd add that the easiest way to strip polish off your boots is to hold them over a boiling kettle to let the hot stream loosen the polish. You can then gently rub the polish off using a cloth. (It's how cadets do it
