or Connect
Styleforum › Forums › Men's Style › Classic Menswear › whnay.'s good taste thread
New Posts  All Forums:Forum Nav:

whnay.'s good taste thread - Page 40

post #586 of 12606
Damn SB, great contribution. Others will disagree but I really like #1 and #2.
post #587 of 12606
Can you guys start wearing plain white linen squares so your fit stop sucking? I'll let you know when you're good enough to get your other squares out. Thanks.
post #588 of 12606
Quote:
Originally Posted by whnay. View Post

Damn SB, great contribution. Others will disagree but I really like #1 and #2.
What's not to like? I like 3 best and 1 is close.
post #589 of 12606
Quote:
Originally Posted by sugarbutch View Post

Warning: Spoiler! (Click to show)
bce444bd.jpg
4dc0dd69.jpg
2f8f2615.jpg
20120105.jpg
41df7bcd.jpg

#1 is pretty good. My only complaint is that the cream motif in the square is slightly repetitive of the white dots in the tie--not because they are both the same-shaped motif, but because they are both dotted (even if not both actual dots).

#2 through #4 I don't like. #2 and #3 suffer from having pocket squares matched to closely to their shirts. The tie in #2 also clashes with the shirt--too close in saturation. I mostly blame the shirt. That slightly darker blue is hard to wear. I don;t like the square in #4--again repeating the dotting in the tie.

#5 is okay. Though I'd prefer to see something other than a plain white linen square. If you want to keep the square, I'd swap in a blue-on-white patterned shirt.
post #590 of 12606

Nice work SB!

post #591 of 12606
Quote:
Originally Posted by Fuuma View Post

Can you guys start wearing plain white linen squares so your fit stop sucking? I'll let you know when you're good enough to get your other squares out. Thanks.

Ouch. While pocket square fail is the most common fail, I don't think you can just sub in a white linen one and expect to solve everything. Like white shirts, white squares are not nearly as universally applicable as many might think. They tend to look terrible with solid shirts, whether white or blue.
post #592 of 12606
I like the tie in #3, SB - who makes it?
post #593 of 12606
Quote:
Originally Posted by sugarbutch View Post

Warning: Spoiler! (Click to show)
bce444bd.jpg

I've worn the same combination, only inside-out, or upside down, or maybe sideways:

3S54L.jpg

Foofed: Spoiler-ed the quoted image. Everyone, please spoiler these on your own so we don't clog up the thread. Thanks.
post #594 of 12606
Sugarbutch, I think all these are great. I like 1 and 2 best.
post #595 of 12606
Quote:
Originally Posted by sugarbutch View Post

bce444bd.jpgWarning: Spoiler! (Click to show)
4dc0dd69.jpg
2f8f2615.jpg
20120105.jpg
41df7bcd.jpg

thumbs up
post #596 of 12606
Quote:
Originally Posted by mafoofan View Post

Ouch. While pocket square fail is the most common fail, I don't think you can just sub in a white linen one and expect to solve everything. Like white shirts, white squares are not nearly as universally applicable as many might think. They tend to look terrible with solid shirts, whether white or blue.

I honestly like them with everything, what is more t I generally hate the "let's add a colour to complete the spectrum" technique you guys are using, preferring something close to another element in the fit, say a blue ps w. a blue tie (obviously not the same blue at all), the way you guys do it, it just looks like those leather bars gay sex codes and is visually jarring. I just know that if I had to deal with tie/shirt/ps/suit/shoes and was concerned with colour, pattern and texture (as you are), I'd remove one constraint by going for white linen. I am of course caricaturing as I found many of the matches posted here to be visually pleasing, although maybe overcomplicated by including too much colour for my arguably personal taste.

The series of MC thread has influenced me in dressing menswear-ish today (navy blazer + blue stripped bd+white linen square+apc raw+tan suede clarks), however wearing coloured squares often is where I draw the poofy line.
post #597 of 12606
Quote:
Originally Posted by Eustace Tilley View Post

Nice work SB!

+1. i think i like 4 the best. not sure why, i just find it pleasing to the eye.
post #598 of 12606
To be fair, I'm not sure anyone else is really towing the "fill-in the spectrum" line other than me. Also, I would never match a blue square to a blue shirt like you suggest.

Did you think my outfits were that bad? Interested in your feedback. Probably too much color--though I think I am less elaborately colorful than many, if not most.
post #599 of 12606
My approach with squares (going back to how my dad taught me to dress and how to wear a pochette) is closer to what Fuuma is saying than to the "add a color" approach. I intuitively pick a square that picks up a minor color in the tie or shirt, or that is of a different gradations of a color already there.

Then again, probably 50% of the time, there's already a square in the breast pocket, I take a look and think "eh, good enough".

I do not subscribe to the white square theory though - I think those rarely look good with anything that's not uber-CBD in an old banker/lawyer kind of way, because it just adds a layer of formality that more often than not I'm trying to avoid. If anything, I like my square to soften the overall CBD look, not make me look stiffer.
post #600 of 12606
Interesting.

Also, filling in the spectrum is not the same as adding color. At least, not in my take.
New Posts  All Forums:Forum Nav:
  Return Home
  Back to Forum: Classic Menswear
Styleforum › Forums › Men's Style › Classic Menswear › whnay.'s good taste thread