I finally got to see the game late last night after work. My thoughts (having not read the previous posts)
Liverpool had the run of the first half and then the second was pretty even (i.e. crappy for both). Pennant ran circles around Milan's L back. But then he (the back) seemed to pick it up in the 2nd half.
Overall the game was pretty lousy. Not great play. In particular, I expected more from virtually everyone on the pitch. Only Pennant and Inzaghi can really be credited with much. I expected a fast-paced game and we didn't see anything near "fast".
Gerrard should have scored--I was amazed he didn't.
On the first goal Inzaghi did not handle the ball by my view--he moved just slightly so it skimmed his chest. But the goal should have counted for Pirlo, anyway, Inzaghi's part seemed pretty accidental.
Inzaghi's second, however, was great. Beautiful work by all involved.
One could make an argument that Kuyt's goal was actually offsides. The ball glanced off a Milan defender's head on its way to him, but that's usually not enough for me to rule that as the last touch. Assuming the earlier header (from Crouch?) was the last touch, Kuyt was clearly offsides. In the end it doesn't matter.
The officiating was horrible. But it went both ways. I think this contributed to the choppy-ness of the first half.
Kudos to Maldini for #5. And let's note, it's Seedorf's 4th and with his 3rd club: Ajax, Real Madrid, and AC Milan (x2).
Overall, it was not a brilliant game. And I note that Rafa is cleaning house already this morning. We can count the following out of any more Liverpool games (some announced earlier): Fowler, Dudeck, Zenden, and someone else got the boot this morning too. He's really overhauling the squad.