Most weekdays I shave in the shower with a Mach III and Anthony Logistics unscented shave cream. I've found that some of the tube creams tend to stay creamy (i.e. do not lather well), but this one doesn't have that problem--it lathers up quickly in my hands. I've only recently discovered it, but so far I've been very pleased.
For weekends and special occasions when I feel like taking more time, I shave at the sink with a Merkur safety razor and badger brush. For this I prefer Truefitt and Hill, but I've used Proraso before and it also works well. FWIW, I think Proraso is the best value at its price point, but T&H is probably worth the extra cost.