I received my first pair of Allen Edmonds today (my first 'real' shoes). I chose the Vernon in black. Using the sizing guide on the AE website I determined I was a 9E. However, the shoe has a slight heel slip and is really tight by the outside toes, arch seems ok, if anything could be moved up a tad.
Should I send them back for an 8.5EEE?
Should I send them back for an 8.5EEE?
