Looking for a little sizing advice on the Trench Boot. My Brannock is an 8.5D, but I am actually right between 8 and 8.5. In my 7 and 4 lasted AE I am an 8D. I also tried on a RedWing Beckman in 8.5 and it was too large. They ordered the 8 for me to try, but I haven't gone back yet. Tony @ OakStreet did recommend an 8.5 solely based on my 8.5 Brannock, but I am technically just short of 8.5. Any advice?
I was in a similar dilemma, I ordered the 8 and it turned out to be a little too snug; I returned it and got a 8.5 which fit more appropriately. Go for the larger size.