I'm about to pull the trigger on a new pair of dark oak EG oxfords in 82 last.
I want something I can wear with everything from a suit to jeans..which is sort of difficult to do, I think.
I've narrowed it down to the Malvern (classic wingtip) and the Canterbury (u-throat captoe, no medallion).
Canterbury (wrong last and color):
What are your thoughts? Thinking the Malvern might be too conventional, not formal enough for a suit and that the Canterbury is a bit more interesting. At the same time, Malvern might be much better for more casual wear.
Also wondering if a U-throat like the Canterbury will make my feet look too long (I'm an 11).