Edward Green Appreciation: Pictures, Info, and Where to Buy - Page 121
Styleforum Top Picks
Depending on the price, I could be very interested!
Would you happen to know what last they are on?
I paid the Royal Mail shipping, that's it. It says UK9 on the box, but they feel more like a US10EE
This is what they palm off as "Top Drawer" these days so you can understand why the guy is so pissed off, check this out:-
The poor guy wanted MTO with slight modifications, including a storm welt, modified foxing and whiskey Cordovan. They said they could only do them as Top Drawer so they charged him Top Drawer price plus GBP250 for the Cordovan and this is what he got.
Since they refuse to sort the problem out he basically gave them to me for the cost of shipping.
Nice, at that price I might even wear them.
This story just reinforces a lot of the negative comments about EG I have seen made on this thread and others over the years. No way those shoes should have even left the factory.
No, I am NOT going to paste photos of people who are likely to make my life too miserable if they ever found out!!
The shoes? sure, here is the first pic:-
Seems the guy was really badly screwed by them so he just getting rid of everything.
My good luck I guess!
The work on the fancy heels is really bad, but for the price I think I got a real bargain
Usually TD has a fiddleback. Did he specifically request a non-fiddleback waist?
What! It is a disgrace that those shoes ever left the factory and a 100 times worse that they don´t refund the original buyer or give him new shoes. My growing interest in EG took a dive right now. Everyone makes mistakes but it´s in the way you handle those that show what you are, as a person or in business.
I have had dozens of EGs, the majority MTO and never had a single problem. Those are pretty bad though. I'm shocked that EG won't fix the issue. They have been extremely responsive in the past.
From my experience, EG have been brilliant; however, those shoes are concerning. Forgot why EG will not accept them back, how it left the EG factory is shocking.
Yes, all my EG shoes have a TD fiddle back, but I rarely order from EG any longer anyway. Their product has deteriorated quite a lot but really, their product, and especially their customer service, is not worth the money they charge.
This guy I bought these Sandringhams from did not WANT TD Sandringhams, he wanted MTO Sandringhams with HAF sole for country wear. It was Edward Green who INSISTED that they could only produce them as Top Drawer, so that is why he had to pay Top Drawer pricing for what is essentially an MTO shoe.
That is also why these do not have a fiddle back.
Even as an MTO shoe I would simply have refused to accept these, but EG told him they refuse to take them back and they refuse to refund him either. I wish I could photograph them better so that the flaws were a little more visible.
I never realized there were so many people who still thought EG was a premiere brand, it is no secret that EG have not been a premiere brand for quite a few years already so I am not all that surprised.
First, perhaps a hair splitter, but I thought you just paid postage.
Moving on, the Sandringham issue seems like a rare issue with EG MTO given other experiences here (I've only had EG RTW), let alone a second similar MTO issue experienced by the same original purchaser. You seem to be awfully negative towards EG, e.g.:
You want SC's? Let me show you my latest 2 pairs which arrived just in time for the Holidays:-
1- 105 in Burgundy / Merlot marbled finish (with very slight almost imperceptible golden chestnut undertones). Hand polished to perfection with the usual typical SC hand carved and hand finished shoe trees which slip in and fit like high performance racing pistons! None of that cheap crappy Edward Green "one size fits all" rubbish here.
2- 401 Balmoral boot in thick but very soft hide, nice heavy firm but supple scotch grain shaft, sensually soft and smooth inner lining, worked to perfection by the most expert hands. This is what "hand made" is supposed to mean.
Note the particularly beautiful marbled shoe. Coffee and chocolate on a bed of golden butter and bronze. These are absolutely spectacular!
Fit? Well, they feel like all the angels in heaven were sent down to massage your feet all day.
I know they are affiliate SF vendors and I should not say anything bad about them here, but hey, I need to say it like it is, trust me, EG and G&G don't come anywhere even close to SC, not even by a very, very, long, long mile.
At this quality I would be happy to pay St Crispins double the price which the average boring old "yesterday's hero" EG charges for their very average quality with their ill fitting shoe trees, or the over rated GG shoes, but, at similar prices? it is just a no brainer? These SC's are mega bargains, I cannot think of better bang for my buck.
Also, buying SC is a much easier and smoother transaction than any of the annoying experiences I always have with the English MTO and RTW brands.
My only gripe is that SC used to supply boot trees and I am experiencing a little trouble finding boot trees for this pair of 401's
Yet, G&G, being an "English MTO/RTW" brand is ok? I thought they were overrated?
Merry Christmas to you too!
I don't mean to be rude but are you perhaps the same Nick from Bespoke England?
I have been registered with SF for 6 months now and I never realized the owner of the G&G retail site might also be a SF member! LOL!
If you are the same Nick I am the guy who sent you an e-mail with a bunch of urls of G&G stuff I am interested in buying, I really do hope you have had time to look through them because I am a REALLY keen buyer!
If you are not the same Nick, well, perhaps you could sell me some shoes anyway ;-)
I discovered St Crispins during a visit to Hawaii (Leather Soul).
I will RARELY buy another pair of G&G or EG again. I can't understand why St Crispins are not double the price of EG and G&G, but hey, for a genuine hand made shoe I am NOT complaining!
Has anyone else noticed how crappy Edward Green's shoe trees are these days? Why would you pay the Edward Green price for their really crappy service, their obscenely bad customer attitude and their declining quality when you can buy GENUINE hand made St Crispins shoes for the same price?
Look, I really don't personally care what shoes you prefer (if fact, I love Saint Crispin's as well)...but as HRoi said:
So, having gone out of your way to trash EG and, frankly, G&G, what's the deal?
Edited by RedDevil10 - 12/30/12 at 8:26pm