or Connect
Styleforum › Forums › Men's Style › Classic Menswear › Mr. Ned vs. Brooklyn Tailors
New Posts  All Forums:Forum Nav:

Mr. Ned vs. Brooklyn Tailors

post #1 of 73
Thread Starter 

I'm in the market for a custom suit, and after a great deal of research, I have narrowed it down to these to places.  Mr. Ned is the darling of Style Forum (at least for an approximately $1000 suit), so he was my top choice, but then I came across this place Brooklyn Tailors, which I've never really even heard mentioned here.

 

I need a very modern suit.  Trim all around, high arm holes, narrow-ish lapels, working buttonholes on the sleeves.  You know the look...  I often work with celebrities, so I need to try to fit in.  I am starting to think that Brooklyn Tailors may be able to better give me what I need.  What do you all think?

 

If nothing else, I have noticed that Mr. Ned photos are very difficult to come by, so let this serve as a compilation of what I could find.  Apologies in advance if you see your photo posted.  I got some of them from Style Forum.

 

Photos from both places are below.  Please let me know what you think.  Obviously the sleeves, pants, and jacket are a bit short in some of the Brooklyn Tailors photos, but that's not a tremendously difficult fix.

 

Mr. Ned http://mrnednyc.com/

 


LL

 

LL

 

LL

 

LL

 

LL

 

LL

 

 

Brooklyn Tailors coming in the next post...

 
 
 
 
post #2 of 73
Thread Starter 

Brooklyn Tailors

 

LL

 

LL

 

LL

 

LL

 

LL

 

LL

post #3 of 73
Thread Starter 

Edit: See below for more photos.

post #4 of 73
Thread Starter 

Brooklyn Tailors http://www.brooklyntailors.net/

 

LL

 

LL

 

LL

 

LL

 

LL

 

LL

post #5 of 73
If I were you I would go to Mr. Ned over Brooklyn Tailors. Brooklyn Tailors is probably a MTM that sends things to Martin Greenfield.
post #6 of 73
Thread Starter 
Quote:
Originally Posted by patrickBOOTH View Post

If I were you I would go to Mr. Ned over Brooklyn Tailors. Brooklyn Tailors is probably a MTM that sends things to Martin Greenfield.


For what it's worth, the website claims to be completely bespoke.

post #7 of 73
Quote:
Originally Posted by Mister F View Post



For what it's worth, the website claims to be completely bespoke.

I highly doubt it.
post #8 of 73
Quote:
Originally Posted by patrickBOOTH View Post

I highly doubt it.

nod[1].gif MTM at best, shoddy suits for hipsters at worst.
post #9 of 73
These BB guys started less than a year ago; Mr. Ned is your man. Hands down. He can even give you that skinny, narrow, slim look that you will not be wearing in two years time.
post #10 of 73
Thread Starter 

Thanks everyone!  I happen to think the Brooklyn Tailors suits look pretty good.  No?  I see your reservations about them being bespoke, though.

 

If anyone has any other suggestions for a suit in New York at about $1000, give or take a couple hundred, I'd love to hear them.
 

Quote:
Originally Posted by Lonneker View Post

These BB guys started less than a year ago; Mr. Ned is your man. Hands down. He can even give you that skinny, narrow, slim look that you will not be wearing in two years time.


 

Can Mr. Ned do the skinny look?  I haven't seen any photos of him doing that, and a lot of people say it takes two or three suits before he even gets the more conservative look down.  I obviously don't want to end up with a poorly fitting suit, and I'm afraid of ending up with that, since this style isn't Mr. Ned's specialty.

 

And yes, I see your point about not wearing it in two years.  Unfortunately, I need to wear it now.  I go to events with celebrities and often need to fit in with them.

post #11 of 73
Quote:
Originally Posted by Mister F View Post

Thanks everyone!  I happen to think the Brooklyn Tailors suits look pretty good.  No?  I see your reservations about them being bespoke, though.

If anyone has any other suggestions for a suit in New York at about $1000, give or take a couple hundred, I'd love to hear them.

 


 
Can Mr. Ned do the skinny look?  I haven't seen any photos of him doing that, and a lot of people say it takes two or three suits before he even gets the more conservative look down.  I obviously don't want to end up with a poorly fitting suit, and I'm afraid of ending up with that, since this style isn't Mr. Ned's specialty.

And yes, I see your point about not wearing it in two years.  Unfortunately, I need to wear it now.  I go to events with celebrities and often need to fit in with them.

I don't think the BT suits look very good. I don't want to open up a proper fit discussion right now, but skinny has nothing to do with proper fit, which these suits don't have. If you want to be measured by a hipster stylist to have your measurements sent off to a far away land to get made then go for it. If you want a suit made with somebody with decades of experience that knows how things should fit and you get to talk to her person cutting the fabric then go to Mr. Ned. All in all skinny is easy. These are the two cheapest options in NYC, fwiw. Cheapest by a lot.
post #12 of 73
I know both companies very well
BT makes their suits in a country far far away. nice people. if the look is what you want, then use them, since that is what they do best.

Bespoke is a useless term.

Varm at Mr. Ned can make you a shrunken suit, but needs to be prodded into it.
you would also be best to bring photos of what you are looking for.
post #13 of 73
Quote:
Originally Posted by Mister F View Post


* * * Can Mr. Ned do the skinny look?  I haven't seen any photos of him doing that, and a lot of people say it takes two or three suits before he even gets the more conservative look down.  I obviously don't want to end up with a poorly fitting suit, and I'm afraid of ending up with that, since this style isn't Mr. Ned's specialty.

And yes, I see your point about not wearing it in two years.  Unfortunately, I need to wear it now.  I go to events with celebrities and often need to fit in with them.
Quote:
Originally Posted by patrickBOOTH View Post

I don't think the BT suits look very good. I don't want to open up a proper fit discussion right now, but skinny has nothing to do with proper fit, which these suits don't have. If you want to be measured by a hipster stylist to have your measurements sent off to a far away land to get made then go for it. If you want a suit made with somebody with decades of experience that knows how things should fit and you get to talk to her person cutting the fabric then go to Mr. Ned. All in all skinny is easy. These are the two cheapest options in NYC, fwiw. Cheapest by a lot.
Quote:
Originally Posted by Shirtmaven View Post

I know both companies very well
BT makes their suits in a country far far away. nice people. if the look is what you want, then use them, since that is what they do best.
Bespoke is a useless term.
Varm at Mr. Ned can make you a shrunken suit, but needs to be prodded into it.
you would also be best to bring photos of what you are looking for.


I think that the BT suits looks horrible. Too short, too tight. But, if this is the look that you want, go there. It makes no sense going to another tailor and asking him to duplicate another look. Most tailors would refuse.

On the other hand, if you want a suit that fits, go to Mr. Ned.

Good luck.
post #14 of 73
Quote:
Originally Posted by patrickBOOTH View Post

I don't think the BT suits look very good. ....proper fit, which these suits don't have. ....

+1; they just don't fit well.
Quote:
Originally Posted by Mister F View Post

....
Can Mr. Ned do the skinny look? I haven't seen any photos of him doing that, and a lot of people say it takes two or three suits before he even gets the more conservative look down. I obviously don't want to end up with a poorly fitting suit, and I'm afraid of ending up with that, since this style isn't Mr. Ned's specialty....

You raise a good point; I don't think he will be happy to make you a suit like that, but whatever he ends up making, it will presumably fit better than what you get from BT.
post #15 of 73
Quote:
Originally Posted by Mister F View Post

LL

Just to clarify, this is me c. fall 2007 and it is not a Mr. Ned suit. It's a RTW from Pal Zileri Sartoriale.
Quote:
Originally Posted by Mister F View Post

LL

Damn, Jason Marshall dapper as ever.
New Posts  All Forums:Forum Nav:
  Return Home
  Back to Forum: Classic Menswear
Styleforum › Forums › Men's Style › Classic Menswear › Mr. Ned vs. Brooklyn Tailors