I was a HUGE fan of them early on, and then gradually lost interest. It seems like as the price of things went up, the quality went down, and it stopped being a radically better value than competitors. Combined with a number of customer service snaffus, and quality control, I just stopped being pumped up about everlane. Now I get all my stuff from Gustin.
My at cost belt and my vegetable tanned leather belt are still amazing from them. Wear them all the time.
Funny you mention that; my at-cost belt is one of my most-worn belts, although I haven't bought anything from Everlane in years.