I used to buy most of my sweaters from BR before I found SF. I don't know if their quality has goine down recently, but I have 7 or 8 year old sweaters from them that just won't die. I haven't had any issues with quality with their merino wool ones. Their cotton/wool blends did not last though so stay away from those. I'm a size 44 and their large fits me well. I don't buy them any more because they are a pretty good value and everyone wears them and I HATE showing up somewhere in the same sweater as somone else.
I have a really thick cashmere sweater from them, but it is at least seven years old and I have not seen anything like that there in a long time. I also have a BR monogram cashmere sweater that is about three years old, still looks good, and got me a complement two days ago when I wore it to work.