Out of these watches, which would you choose to wear and why?

Second row "gold" one.
I like it because it is the simplest.

Top row right.

for a formal look - top row, white face and black strap
for a casual look - one of the top row weekenders

Umm, OP what's your opinion? do you like white or black face? do you like gold or silver bezel? do you want a nato strap or fake leather (you know you can switch them out right). Not to be a dbag, but do you buy all clothes and accessories based on what others think? If you go thru the pages of SF for a while, especially the WAYWRN thread, you'll see that people find a style and go with it. there will ALWAYS be someone who likes it, and ALWAYS someone who hates it. Nature of the beast. So decide what's important to you and don't look back.

FWIW, I own the top row, 2nd from the right. $25 at target plus $15 a pop for 3 other straps. It's my go-to casual watch now and I don't care if it gets beat up.

I think the 2nd one from the right (top and bottom rows) both look simple and nice. You might want to get the black face bottom right one too. Now you make me feel like getting new watches too...

(Right-click and 'Open In New Window' to see full size)
Top left or Bottom right...and of those I wold choose bottom right.
Welcome to Styleforum.