For everyone's reference these are my "Dark Brown" Oxfords:
These are the shoes on the site:
I will say, now that I have worn them, that they are the nicest shoes I own and that they are very well made.
The key difference between these and a shoe twice as expensive would be in the quality control.
Looking at the picture you can clearly see the left shoe (the one on the right in the picture) has had the sole stitched on sloppily and unevenly.
Even the brouging is uneven.
A company with higher quality control wouldn't let these shoes out and would have lower tolerances for a shoe like this being produced in the first place.
Regardless, I love these shoes and for the amount I paid AU$190, they are fantastic.