or Connect
Styleforum › Forums › Men's Style › Classic Menswear › How formal is a V-neck sweater?
New Posts  All Forums:Forum Nav:

How formal is a V-neck sweater?

post #1 of 11
Thread Starter 
I work where the minimum dress code is Slacks/Shirt/Tie. Does adding, say, a grey wool v-neck to this lessen the formality?
post #2 of 11
No, but a machine gun does dramatically.

289
post #3 of 11

It may, but it would probably be okay to wear.

 

I don't see it as 'informal," per se, although it could possibly be seen to detract from the technical formality of the tie.

If I were to take a chance and choose one side, I would be in favor of the sweater.

There may be people at your job who are used to seeing the components of the dress code, and judging it based on their presence rather than the way they are worn or presented. For them, it might seem "off" somehow, since the sweater would be covering the body of your shirt and a good portion of the tie blade.

My personal opinion is that some sort of garment should be worn over a shirt and tie, since the combination is meant to be worn under something else. A sport coat or blazer would be the most appropriate, but since those are not required, the next best thing would be a V-neck sweater of exactly the type you have mentioned. It will streamline the ensemble, making the end result far more cohesive and complete. The "V" is good, as well, because it allows your tie to show, demonstrating that you have indeed incorporated the required components.

 

Medium to dark grey, navy, burgundy, charcoal, and tan are all potentially acceptable colors. Charcoal is probably the safest. Patterns and holiday imagery are best avoided unless golfing or attending a holiday party. Argyle, if not very carefully chosen and worn in the appropriate situation, will look uninspired or trite. A solid, subdued V-neck sweater is generally going to be well received, though.

 

You should give it a try. The worst that can come of it is that you'll be looked at a little oddly, and maybe asked to take it off, but that seems unlikely. The dress code you describe seems to align most closely to "Business Casual," in which a discreet sweater is usually just fine.

 

-VF

 

post #4 of 11
Quote:
Originally Posted by acridsheep View Post

No, but a machine gun does dramatically.
289


Only a pistol-caliber weapon with a collapsible stock.

 

Fixed-stock firearms chambered in rifle calibers are suitable for wear with a sport coat and most suits.

 

Handguns tend to be acceptable at any level of formality, although a sleeker blued design such as a Colt M1908 or Walther PPK, preferably chambered in .380 Auto, is considered a more desirable accompaniment to evening dress.

 

Great movie, by the way.

 

-VF

post #5 of 11
Quote:
Originally Posted by Von Franz View Post



Only a pistol-caliber weapon with a collapsible stock.

Fixed-stock firearms chambered in rifle calibers are suitable for wear with a sport coat and most suits.

Handguns tend to be acceptable at any level of formality, although a sleeker blued design such as a Colt M1908 or Walther PPK, preferably chambered in .380 Auto, is considered a more desirable accompaniment to evening dress.

Great movie, by the way.

-VF

Lol post of the day.

To the OP, quick answer no. Feel free to wear a vneck sweater.
post #6 of 11
Thread Starter 
Thanks for the help, guys.

I liked where you said:
Quote:
My personal opinion is that some sort of garment should be worn over a shirt and tie, since the combination is meant to be worn under something else. A sport coat or blazer would be the most appropriate, but since those are not required, the next best thing would be a V-neck sweater of exactly the type you have mentioned.

I do really like the shirt/tie combo, but something about *just* a shirt and tie bothers me. Always feel like I'm missing something.

Anyways, lovely advice as always.


For clarification, as to my OP, the dress code is "two-piece minimum". Exactly that, which most people interpret as Shirt + Tie.
post #7 of 11
^^^ Falling Down, got to watch that again. A film full of wierdo's but a 90's classic.
post #8 of 11

I would agree with Von Franz, in that it is probably perfectly acceptable in your work situation. But on a scale of formality, adding the sweater is definitely less formal, although it does link much more to my personal taste. Also make sure it is a v-neck to show off the shirt and tie appropriately.

post #9 of 11
For sweaters, thin & smooth is more formal, and wool is more formal than cotton. Think merino wool or cashmere.

Dark green can be another acceptable color for a business casual sweater.
post #10 of 11
Quote:
Originally Posted by Satiar View Post

Thanks for the help, guys.
I liked where you said:
Quote:
My personal opinion is that some sort of garment should be worn over a shirt and tie, since the combination is meant to be worn under something else. A sport coat or blazer would be the most appropriate, but since those are not required, the next best thing would be a V-neck sweater of exactly the type you have mentioned.
I do really like the shirt/tie combo, but something about *just* a shirt and tie bothers me. Always feel like I'm missing something.
Anyways, lovely advice as always.
For clarification, as to my OP, the dress code is "two-piece minimum". Exactly that, which most people interpret as Shirt + Tie.

Definitely agree with wearing JUST a shirt and tie and looking awkward. Only worse is a short sleeved shirt and a 80s style tie with a massive knot and tip reaching one's upper ribcage.
post #11 of 11
Quote:
Originally Posted by Klobber View Post

^^^ Falling Down, got to watch that again. A film full of wierdo's but a 90's classic.

Yeah me too..it has been awhile. ..MD's character was the only sane one in the film.

Back to the thread title 'How formal is a V-neck sweater? '
A V-neck sweater is not formal at all. Wear as many of them as you like.
Welcome to Styleforum Satiar.
New Posts  All Forums:Forum Nav:
  Return Home
  Back to Forum: Classic Menswear
Styleforum › Forums › Men's Style › Classic Menswear › How formal is a V-neck sweater?