or Connect
Styleforum › Forums › Men's Style › Classic Menswear › The Tailors' Thread: Fit Feedback and Alteration Suggestions
New Posts  All Forums:Forum Nav:

The Tailors' Thread: Fit Feedback and Alteration Suggestions - Page 227

post #3391 of 5101
Quote:
Originally Posted by Dingusberry View Post

Should I return the jacket if I need to shorten it that much? I have too short arms, every jackets have always too long sleeves. 

Well that's up to you. I'm just letting you know that the procedure to shorten working cuff sleeves from the shoulder is risky period...very risky when done beyond 1". If you've had it done before by a good tailor and you're happy with the result, then by all means do proceed. If you have only had sleeves shortened from the hem and you're unsure of the tailor's skill, I'd proceed with caution. Also, if the sleeves are that long, are you sure the jacket is the right length? Usually a maker who makes working cuff sleeves on RTW jackets is pretty confident in their measurements/cuts. You see this with Tom Ford. 

post #3392 of 5101
Quote:
Originally Posted by michaelyork View Post

How is the fit on this suit?  Is the fit alright or is it too long, or too big, or?  I need to hem pants, get the sleeves done, take off basting thread, etc.

Any advice gratefully appreciated!   

 

Created with GIMPCreated with GIMP

 

 

 

 

 

Created with GIMPCreated with GIMP

 

Created with GIMPCreated with GIMPCreated with GIMP

 

 

 

 

 

Created with GIMPCreated with GIMP

 

 

 

Created with GIMPCreated with GIMP

 

Created with GIMPCreated with GIMPCreated with GIMP

The back of the jacket may need work. Too hard to tell with the way you've taken the pics. FYI, the posing isn't necessary...it only distorts what a tailor needs to see to comment on fit. Check the first post in the whole thread for instructions on how to post proper pics. It's for your best interest. Also, I don't think the shirt sleeves are too long. I think they're too loose which makes them appear too long. They should fall just below the break in your wrist right onto the base of your thumb. There should be a bit of blousing in the sleeve so that when you extend your arm, say, to talk on the phone you can still show the appropriate amount of cuff. This is a Flusser-ism...and it makes sense.

post #3393 of 5101

I think your jacket lenght is fine...rule is it should be around the base of your thumb so that's fine. you should have it take in at the waist to enhance the shape of your body...the shirt though (not sure if you are asking opinions on that as well) but you should get a custom shirt..you are a fairly fit guy..it's too bad to wear a shirt that makes you look overweight

post #3394 of 5101
Needs better pictures. Put a tie on or button top button to test for collar gap. pants too long unless its your personal preference.
Warning: Spoiler! (Click to show)
Quote:
Originally Posted by michaelyork View Post

How is the fit on this suit?  Is the fit alright or is it too long, or too big, or?  I need to hem pants, get the sleeves done, take off basting thread, etc.



Any advice gratefully appreciated!   



 



Created with GIMP
Created with GIMP







Created with GIMP
Created with GIMP



Created with GIMP
Created with GIMP

Created with GIMP






Warning: Spoiler! (Click to show)
Created with GIMP

Created with GIMP




Created with GIMP
Created with GIMP



Created with GIMP
Created with GIMP

Created with GIMP

post #3395 of 5101

Quote:
Originally Posted by OTCtailor View Post

The back of the jacket may need work. Too hard to tell with the way you've taken the pics. FYI, the posing isn't necessary...it only distorts what a tailor needs to see to comment on fit. Check the first post in the whole thread for instructions on how to post proper pics. It's for your best interest. Also, I don't think the shirt sleeves are too long. I think they're too loose which makes them appear too long. They should fall just below the break in your wrist right onto the base of your thumb. There should be a bit of blousing in the sleeve so that when you extend your arm, say, to talk on the phone you can still show the appropriate amount of cuff. This is a Flusser-ism...and it makes sense.

 
 
OTCtailor, the back of the jacket has two vents which are still sewn shut.  I have yet to remove the stitches there.  I very removed the stitches to take these photos, because it really did look awkward without the natural flow the vents give to the shape.  
The pants are not hemmed either, just rolled up on the inside.  
Thanks for the tips about photos, I'll read the first post carefully.   
The shirt is too large, I think--I know.  I just put on the first shirt I could find to try the suit for fit.
 
Quote:
Originally Posted by GastonSharp View Post

I think your jacket lenght is fine...rule is it should be around the base of your thumb so that's fine. you should have it take in at the waist to enhance the shape of your body...the shirt though (not sure if you are asking opinions on that as well) but you should get a custom shirt..you are a fairly fit guy..it's too bad to wear a shirt that makes you look overweight

 

Yeah, you're right, the shirt is too big.  I should try sizing down and then taking in the torso.

 

Quote:
Originally Posted by lychyrychy View Post

Needs better pictures. Put a tie on or button top button to test for collar gap. pants too long unless its your personal preference.
Warning: Spoiler! (Click to show)
[/SPOILER]

pants aren't hemmed...i'll post a proper pic, with tie, accessories, etc. once i take all the basting threads off the suit.  thanks.

post #3396 of 5101
Blue MTM edited.JPG 535k .JPG file
Grey OTR edited.JPG 566k .JPG file


Hello gentlemen.

Please pardon the photo quality in advance. I am not really a photo enthusiast (Read: I lack the SLR Pro and Tripod) and I don't really have friends I am comfortable asking for a small fashion photoshoot (maybe I need different friends haha?). My question only concerns the button stance on a RLBL MTM commission that I had made for the MTM even (i.e. same cost as OTR). My jacket came in with a higher button stance than requested and I have been offered to do one of the following:

-Keep the jacket I have (I am not sure if it actually may look better than the lower button stance b/c my chest is about as wide as my hips)
-Change the jacket for an OTR model in the same cloth (first time trying the MTM with them so purposely tried a fabric so I could swap it if this happened)
-Get the jacket recut with a lower button stance (I am a bit concerned that a) it will take forever b) they will mess something else up since they'll give me another block pattern that may not fit me as well)

Any thoughts? Is my lower body relevant to decide this? I'll bite the bullet and just ask someone to take a pic if so.
Look forward to your thoughts and any recommendation for an alterations tailor in Manhattan or Brooklyn that can take a look in person as I think I'd prefer that but have no idea who I'd go to. I have read the recommendations for pepino and have gone to wilfred (ruined pants for me) but I don't have the kind of cash it takes to mess up a suit and chalk it up to a data point on my suiting experience so if anyone has someone that's reliable and not against a younger slimmer fit I'd greatly appreciate it.
Thanks in advance for the pearls of wisdom/suggestions.

Jcep
Edited by jcep - 6/10/13 at 10:37am
post #3397 of 5101
jcep: We can't pardon the photo quality because the critique you seek depends utterly on their quality. Please go back to the first post in the thread for guidelines on picture taking, and then get someone to take pictures in the prescribed poses.
post #3398 of 5101
Recent Kent Wang MTM suit:





Overall, I'm pretty pleased with the fit, but I welcome other opinions and suggestions for possible tailoring to this suit as well as adjustments to future MTM suits.
post #3399 of 5101
Quote:
Originally Posted by sugarbutch View Post

jcep: We can't pardon the photo quality because the critique you seek depends utterly on their quality. Please go back to the first post in the thread for guidelines on picture taking, and then get someone to take pictures in the prescribed poses.

Completely understand Sugarbutch. It makes sense. Would it be possible for you or maybe some of the other members (ideally Despos, Jeffrey, or OTC tailor ) to recommend someone in Manhattan or Brooklyn that could look at this in person? I have gone to Wilfred and the guys at the Tailoring Room but the former messed up a garment irreparably and the latter is more for simpler stuff so I guess I'm looking for someone with equivalent skills to the tailors on this thread. Any ideas? I did use the search function but it seems to me that maybe someone comparable in skill would be a bespoke suitmaker and since I'm not a customer I'm not sure if he or she would take the time to see me.

Any thoughts sugarbutch or anyone else?
post #3400 of 5101
Edited (wrong pics)
post #3401 of 5101
Quote:
Originally Posted by sugarbutch View Post

jcep: We can't pardon the photo quality because the critique you seek depends utterly on their quality. Please go back to the first post in the thread for guidelines on picture taking, and then get someone to take pictures in the prescribed poses.

Will this do? ( blue is MTM grey is OTR)








post #3402 of 5101
I'm in San Francisco, so I can't recommend anyone.
post #3403 of 5101
No worries Sugarbutch. Appreciate the response, hopefully some of the other members can help or I can go to one of the alterations tailors here in NY (or back to ralph lauren even) with some instructions to serve as guidance.
post #3404 of 5101

When taking in a jacket for waist supression (double vented) do they take it in on the sides that run up from the vents? That's where they marked mine yesterday and I was a little suspicious about it but was too puss to say anything.. I can call now and tell them to not touch it or change which seams they alter if need be.

post #3405 of 5101

 

 

Red lines are where he marked it. This is not my jacket. The below one is though. I was going for maybe .5" total suppression but he marked more than that..

 

New Posts  All Forums:Forum Nav:
  Return Home
  Back to Forum: Classic Menswear
Styleforum › Forums › Men's Style › Classic Menswear › The Tailors' Thread: Fit Feedback and Alteration Suggestions