Quote:
Originally Posted by
antexit 
I think the cap is probably the best solution, or maybe a stiff wool bucket hat. But neither one of them are great. I really don't know about earmuffs, except maybe really bright f-you ones.
I have an astrakhan coat and hat that I wore for awhile, and still wear in the evenings, but one on the way to work (with just the coat) someone told me I looked like Ric Flair.
You can get the wool flat caps with earmuffs attached. That would be a good option if you're afraid of the fedora. Or hell, just skip the earmuffs- your ears will be cold, but you get used to it, and the rest of your head is much warmer than it would be otherwise. And it allows for nicer and better looking caps- Irish tweed, for example, would be a great option.
You really shouldn't be scared of the brimmed hat. A moderate sized brim with tailored clothing and an overcoat looks fine, but if you don't wear it naturally it'll look off on you. Basically, if you don't think you can pull it off, you can't, and if you do, you can.