or Connect
Styleforum › Forums › Culture › Business, Careers & Education › Business legality and tax question
New Posts  All Forums:Forum Nav:

Business legality and tax question

post #1 of 9
Thread Starter 
Hello all. I am thinking of starting a business. This business will have zero profit and be 110% legal. In fact, the idea will seem stupid to you if you have half an inkling of common sense. But my question is not on whether it is a sound business plan. My question has to do with legalities and tax implications. 

Illustrative example of business:

1) Business purchases Widget X from itself at the retail price of $10. Total business expense = $10. 

2) Business receives revenue from above mentioned transaction.  Total revenue = $10. 

3) Net income = revenue - expenses = $10 - $10 = $0. 

Question for the intelligentsia:

1) Is the above example "legal" in and of itself? Is it legal to have the customer and the seller be the same entity when operating as a business? Is it legal for some business vehicles but not for others (e.g. Sole propietorships, LLCs, s-corps, c-corps, etc.)?

2) From a tax perspective, would the above in and of itself result in zero taxable income?

Thanks. 

PS I understand that the devil is always in the details, but assuming everything else was 100% legal and that no other information is provided, what are the answers to the questions listed? I also understand that a lawyer and tax professional are required before undertaking any business venture and this fact is not lost on me. Just testing the waters here.
post #2 of 9
I'm in no way qualified to answer this but I suspect it is not.

Reasoning: A business can't sell to its self, that is simply a transfer of assets. Two separate companies with the same owner could do it, but you would incur costs such as taxes and costs (accountants filing year-end documents for example) so you would result in a net loss.

From a tax point of view, you have two companies operating at a loss, which means they don't pay tax (in the UK at least) but YMMV.
post #3 of 9
Thread Starter 
Thanks Blackhood. In essence I am trying to create a vehicle (or vehicles) in which I can purchase assets from myself. There is no catch and nothing shady. Would some sort of investment vehicle be a smarter approach? The net returns would end up being zero. 

I know this is bordering on way to technical legally for a message board, but what the hell, it's worth a shot. 
post #4 of 9
Why would you want to do that? :s
post #5 of 9
Quote:
Originally Posted by MetroStyles View Post

Thanks Blackhood. In essence I am trying to create a vehicle (or vehicles) in which I can purchase assets from myself. There is no catch and nothing shady. Would some sort of investment vehicle be a smarter approach? The net returns would end up being zero. 

I know this is bordering on way to technical legally for a message board, but what the hell, it's worth a shot. 

You trying to profit from credit card benefits?

Edit: As Blackhood said, you definitely can't do it if you and the business entity are one and the same. That said, you're dealing with a separate entity when it's a corporation. If you are looking to score off of credit card benefits, there may be a caveat in the contract that prevents this from happening.
post #6 of 9
Nice spam bump.

Regarding the OP - I believe Mr. Fastow of Enron had this exact same idea of creating fictitious revenue...
post #7 of 9
Google "transfer pricing." I'm too lazy to elaborate.
post #8 of 9
Hire Skadden, they'll figure it out.
post #9 of 9
Quote:
Originally Posted by Grenadier View Post

Hire Skadden, they'll figure it out.

If they can't, they will get Fred Goldberg on the case to fight.
New Posts  All Forums:Forum Nav:
  Return Home
  Back to Forum: Business, Careers & Education
Styleforum › Forums › Culture › Business, Careers & Education › Business legality and tax question