Originally Posted by rach2jlc
I honestly don't think you're really going to want any of the ones you listed there. I've seen or owned all of them but Poggianti, of which I've never heard. (also, keep in mind that there is a big difference between Michael Kors and MICHAEL Michael Kors. Same with D&G and Dolce & Gabbana. But, again, none of them are really worth losing sleep over).
But, as others have mentioned, it is hard to tell exactly what might be best for you without knowing what kind of fit you'd like or how your body type is.
For example, if you like a slimmer fit shirt, then some brands that have very nice quality probably won't fit you well, so all of those nice buttons and beautiful fabrics won't matter much. I'm skinny and like slim shirts, but bought a Lorenzini based on recommendation and it draped me like a tent.
Nevertheless, all around I'd say my favorite dress shirts are Zegna. In terms of fit and fashion, I like Jil Sander, but I couldn't wear these everyday nor could I wear them much under a jacket. But, Zegna is all around a good one for work or play and I don't find the prices to be egregious.
I'm 6ft tall..200lbs...broad shouldered(ex football player) and wear a 17-17.5 with 34/35.
The Ben Sherman shirt seems to form fit very well and is quite slimming, but it's not the best material admittingly.
The Ike Behar "slim" model fits perfectly. I have tried Hugo Boss shirts but they also aren't all that great.
Zegna cuts are excellent. Jhane Bharnes perfect.
Yes, I have the MICHAEL MichaeL Kors and the actual Dolce & Gabanna..not the D & G.
I guess for a broad shouldered stockier frame like mine Matuozo may not be a good fit for me.