I just recently ordered some CT shirts in both slim and tailored.
If you have a 38" chest, I'd definitely go with tailored (their slimmest version).
My main complaints are:
1. The fabric wrinkles VERY easily and seems to stay pressed in. For example, if you are carrying a messenger bag around, expect your shoulders to be terribly wrinkled all day long.
2. The sleeves seem to run a bit long for a standard 33"
3. Lack of gauntlet buttons is pretty annoying, particularly coupled with the sleeve length.
Overall, for $30, a pretty nice fabric, but the wrinkling thing is driving me crazy. Also, the tailored fit shirts have a pretty limited selection, so you might be forced to switch to slim depending on what pattern you want.
How did you order yours? UK website or US website? Also are you in the UK or US? How long did it take?
THanks for your response