or Connect
Styleforum › Forums › Culture › Social Life, Food & Drink, Travel › Any One for a Scotch?
New Posts  All Forums:Forum Nav:

Any One for a Scotch? - Page 53

post #781 of 3205
Quote:
Originally Posted by Jokerman View Post
Would like some suggestions on the top 5 quality Scotch's you guys would want to see in restaurant/bistro type place?

Lagavulin 16
Macallan 18
Highland Park 18
Talisker 10
Balvenie Double Wood

Good range of flavors and prices imo. Not my ideal list mind you, but one that I think would work well in a bistro type setting.
post #782 of 3205
Three newly tasted scotches over the last week for me:

Talisker - one word - delicious
Laphroaig - people actually drink this stuff and enjoy it?
Ardbeg - peaty campfire incredibleness (yes I'm aware I just made up a new word)

Thanks for all the advice given so far in this thread, since I got in here about 6 months ago I've tried:
JW black and green, Chivas, Glenfiddich, Glenlivet, Cragganmore 12, HP12, Dalwhinnie 15, Talisker 10, Lagavulin 16, Laphroaig 10, Ardbeg 10. It's been an incredible ride already, any advice on what to try next?
post #783 of 3205
post #784 of 3205
Quote:
Originally Posted by Waistcoat View Post
Three newly tasted scotches over the last week for me:

Talisker - one word - delicious
Laphroaig - people actually drink this stuff and enjoy it?
Ardbeg - peaty campfire incredibleness (yes I'm aware I just made up a new word)

Thanks for all the advice given so far in this thread, since I got in here about 6 months ago I've tried:
JW black and green, Chivas, Glenfiddich, Glenlivet, Cragganmore 12, HP12, Dalwhinnie 15, Talisker 10, Lagavulin 16, Laphroaig 10, Ardbeg 10. It's been an incredible ride already, any advice on what to try next?

Nice. Curious, what did you not like about the Laphroaig? Surprised you liked the Talisker and Ardbeg (which Ardbeg, BTW?), but hated the Laphroaig. Also, what's your top 3 or 4 of those you mentioned trying? Some good ones there, so just curious.
post #785 of 3205
Waistcoat, you should try some Bowmore next.
post #786 of 3205
Quote:
Originally Posted by sf_esq View Post
Nice. Curious, what did you not like about the Laphroaig? Surprised you liked the Talisker and Ardbeg (which Ardbeg, BTW?), but hated the Laphroaig. Also, what's your top 3 or 4 of those you mentioned trying? Some good ones there, so just curious.

The Laphroaig I really didn't like the medicinal type flavour. Ardbeg (the 10 yo) I liked because the smoke really came through after the peat, but with the Laph all I tasted was iodine, really didn't do much for me.

Top 3 or 4? Hmm. Talisker would probably be number 1, HP12 at 2, Crag 12 and Dal 15 tied at 3, Ardbeg at 4.
Ask me the same thing in a couple of months and the Crag and Ardbeg will probably be higher. The Cragganmore I'm only just starting to fully appreciate and every dram I have I get more and more from. The Ardbeg I'm still getting used to as well, once I can start tasting the other notes besides peat and smoke I'm sure I'll enjoy it even more (although I can taste a really really slight hint of lemon in there already).

Impolyt, which version of the Bowmore?
post #787 of 3205
Quote:
Originally Posted by Waistcoat View Post
Impolyt, which version of the Bowmore?

Start with the 12, the peat is fairly reserved in that vintage, there are some nice chocolate notes in it as well.

Next time you have the Ardbeg Ten try adding some branch water or an ice cube to open it up, you'll start to notice a lot of citrus on the finish, quite nice.
post #788 of 3205
Quote:
Originally Posted by Waistcoat View Post
The Laphroaig I really didn't like the medicinal type flavour. Ardbeg (the 10 yo) I liked because the smoke really came through after the peat, but with the Laph all I tasted was iodine, really didn't do much for me.

Top 3 or 4? Hmm. Talisker would probably be number 1, HP12 at 2, Crag 12 and Dal 15 tied at 3, Ardbeg at 4.
Ask me the same thing in a couple of months and the Crag and Ardbeg will probably be higher. The Cragganmore I'm only just starting to fully appreciate and every dram I have I get more and more from. The Ardbeg I'm still getting used to as well, once I can start tasting the other notes besides peat and smoke I'm sure I'll enjoy it even more (although I can taste a really really slight hint of lemon in there already).

Impolyt, which version of the Bowmore?

I hear you. Laphroaig definitely has more of a medicinal taste, for lack of a better way of describing it. Did you try the Laphroaig 10 or the Quarter Cask? I prefer that to the 10. Which Ardbeg did you try? The Uigeadail is fantastic. Good list. I love the HP 12. Best bang for your buck IMO. The HP 18 is amazing. Haven't tried the Dalmore 15, but liked the 12.
post #789 of 3205
Quote:
Originally Posted by sf_esq View Post
I hear you. Laphroaig definitely has more of a medicinal taste, for lack of a better way of describing it. Did you try the Laphroaig 10 or the Quarter Cask? I prefer that to the 10. Which Ardbeg did you try? The Uigeadail is fantastic. Good list. I love the HP 12. Best bang for your buck IMO. The HP 18 is amazing. Haven't tried the Dalmore 15, but liked the 12.
I had the Ardbeg 10. Uigeadail is more than I'm willing to pay for scotch right now, probably going to be a request for my birthday in September. The Laphroaig I had was the standard 10, had I enjoyed it more I would definitely have bought a bottle being that it's almost half the price of Ardbeg here. I'd like to try the Lap QC, but the only way I can do that here is to buy a bottle, and at $100 that's a bit too much of a risk for my liking. Totally agree on the HP12. Every time I have a dram I'm amazed at just how great it is for an insanely low price. I can't wait to try the 18 in the future.
post #790 of 3205
Quote:
Originally Posted by Waistcoat View Post
I had the Ardbeg 10. Uigeadail is more than I'm willing to pay for scotch right now, probably going to be a request for my birthday in September. The Laphroaig I had was the standard 10, had I enjoyed it more I would definitely have bought a bottle being that it's almost half the price of Ardbeg here. I'd like to try the Lap QC, but the only way I can do that here is to buy a bottle, and at $100 that's a bit too much of a risk for my liking.
Totally agree on the HP12. Every time I have a dram I'm amazed at just how great it is for an insanely low price. I can't wait to try the 18 in the future.

$100 for the QC is steep. Where do you live? I paid about $50 for the QC and $60 for the Uigeadail.
post #791 of 3205
Quote:
Originally Posted by sf_esq View Post
$100 for the QC is steep. Where do you live? I paid about $50 for the QC and $60 for the Uigeadail.

+1 QC sells for $50 at my local
post #792 of 3205
QC 35 here.
post #793 of 3205
Quote:
Originally Posted by jet View Post
QC 35 here.

Costco?
post #794 of 3205
no
post #795 of 3205
Quote:
Originally Posted by jet View Post
QC 35 here.

The fuck? Just paid $50 at my store.

I did save a chunk of change this weekend in MN. Bought a couple staples. Mac12. Laph10. Picked up some balvenie 12 doublewood too.
New Posts  All Forums:Forum Nav:
  Return Home
Styleforum › Forums › Culture › Social Life, Food & Drink, Travel › Any One for a Scotch?