Laphroaig quarter cask. I really enjoy a good peaty scotch.
Any One for a Scotch? - Page 277
Although someone here was just commenting on how Glenfiddich 18 has changed and is pretty good.
Here's what I own:
Laphroaig QC, P/X, an cuan mor, 18
Ardbeg 10, uigeadail
Talisker 10, Dark Storm or DE (I don't remember)
Aberlour 12(?), a'bunadh
Highland Park 12
Auchentoshan Three Wood
Balvenie doublewood (12?)
Walker Double Black, Green
So here are the ones I'm choosing between:
Glenmorangie - heard good things... is it different from what I have? which year is good?
there's original, quinta ruban (port cask) or lasanta (sherry cask) - all $53
Bunnahabhain $52 (was leaning towards this since it's sort of like what I have and like but different)
Glenfarclas 12 Yr. Scotch $58
Glenfarclas 105 Cask Strength $100
Glenfarclas 17 Yr. $100
i was kind of leaning hard towards Glenfarclas just because I've heard such great things. Is the 12 an easy way to get in and worth trying? Am I better off spending $100 instead of $60 and getting something much better? And better to get the higher 105 proof or is that a cheap thrill and better to get the 17 for a fuller more classic version? Basically will Glenfarclass as a group add something that say Aberlour, Auchentoshan , Belvenie, etc aren't giving me, and is the 12 good or better to spring for a higher year version? I don't own a lot and I barely drink so I'm aiming for quality over quantity here.
Suntory Hibiki 'Japanese Harmony' Blended Whisky $65 - my concern is it's totally different 'whisky' and also this isn't the normal one, it's a special edition..
Dalwhinnie Distillers Edition Scotch $70 - is even the regular one any good?
Arran 10 Yr. Scotch $52 - heard the name, worth trying if you only picked one bottle?
Glentauchers 16 - $85. Never heard of but Sarah at Astors recommended it..
Port Dundas 12 ($50) or 18 ($105) single grain - again, never heard of it but it was recommended... I'm just thinking i've never heard of it and still getting my feet wet in this business
Edited by Master-Classter - 10/8/16 at 8:20pm
I would say Bunnahabian because it does have other expressions and independent bottlers that you get more of in the future if you like. That and it is a little different than what you already have. It would probably be closest to the Craggenmore. A little more flavor though. Fruity and woody. Nothing else really pops out to me on your list. Maybe the Glenfarclas 105 but that is pretty close to A'bunadh in styles. The Glenfarclas 17 is nice, but again pretty close to Aberlour. I tend to stay away from Glenmorangie. I've tried a couple of them and never really been impressed.
I havent tried the Dalwhinne but like I've said before most of the distillers editions are great. Arran might be another good choice but that is a pretty standard whisky there. Arran varies a ton now that the distillery is a little older. When I first got started, they had just released some of their first whiskies. Now they are doing some cool finishes and different older age statements. I would stay away from the Glentauchers unless you can get a sample. Not much is out there in terms of offerings from that distillery so that is basically their only offering (not saying that it wont be good)
My vote is the Bunnahabian, Dalwhinne DE, or Arran. Read up the tasting notes and decide yourself. Places like www.thewhiskyexchange.com post a lot of tasting notes for whiskies.
Ended up going with the Bunnahabian. In truth I'd already bought it and come home but then figured I'd post up here just to see in case you all said something radically different like get the Glenfarclass or something else.
So the Hibiki, is it just called Japanese Harmony? Is that the standard expression? Because I thought I saw one that was called Hibiki 12 that was quite a bit more expensive and then a cheaper one called "Harmony" so thought maybe it was some sort of lower end blend.