WAYWRN: MC Casual Style - Page 551
I'd burn return both.
Neither do I think they are especially nice pieces of modern/very casual clothing, nor do they any favour to you.
One thing I had to learn in life was, not to lisen to what the other sex thought would look stylish on men or myself in general.
You do not tell her how to dress, she does not tell you, end of story.
It bewilders me why so many women think they have a clue about mens clothing.
I always listen to what my fiancée thinks about my clothing. She's one of the main reason I want to look good anyway. She's never claimed to know men's clothing, but she has great taste in general so I value her opinion + she's got the basics down pretty well. I give my opinion on her clothes as well. I don't really know how women in general are as guides to men's clothing though, I suspect it might be as you say.
The chinos came out looking very white in the picture. Actually light beige in person.
Shirt: Tommy Hilfiger gingam (Marshall's, $15)
Pants: Bull Head slim fit chino (PacSun clearanced, $24) - (I know, PacSun, what am I, 13 years old? haha)
Belt: Tommy Hilfiger braided belt (Marshall's, $7)
Shoes: Sperry Topsiders, chocolate leather (thrifted, $9)
Watch: Timex Weekender & red/white/blue J. Crew nato strap