or Connect
Styleforum › Forums › Men's Style › Classic Menswear › Nice 4 Button Suit?
New Posts  All Forums:Forum Nav:

Nice 4 Button Suit? - Page 3

post #31 of 48
post #32 of 48
Quote:
Originally Posted by JakeLA View Post

So genius.
post #33 of 48
post #34 of 48
If you were in the Victorian or Edwardian eras, 4 button suits were all the go. But we're not, so don't do it. You'd only look like a douche today.
post #35 of 48
Quote:
Originally Posted by Sanguis Mortuum View Post
I've seen some pics on here of a 4-button tweed coat that actually looked very nice, so it is actually possible. Those pics in the OP though...are just terrible... Here's the one I'm talking about, which looks quite good, though may be considered closer to a 4-roll-3.5 than a true 4-button, and of course as with any coat the bottom button is also not done up: Edit: Fixed image
I agree. It can be done. A tall and slim gent would pull off a 4 button jacket best, imo. Also, a 4 button would unlikely be for a first suit anyway, so by default it would be an extravegance.
post #36 of 48
Quote:
Originally Posted by Man Of Lint View Post
I agree. It can be done. A tall and slim gent would pull off a 4 button jacket best, imo.
Also, a 4 button would unlikely be for a first suit anyway, so by default it would be an extravegance.

I feel like that tweed jacket wouldn't look any better than the others in the thread if it had a shirt and tie underneath it. The lack of them hides the ugliness.
post #37 of 48
Quote:
Originally Posted by lemmy127 View Post
I feel like that tweed jacket wouldn't look any better than the others in the thread if it had a shirt and tie underneath it. The lack of them hides the ugliness.
The tweed and cut saved that jacket, in fact it's starting to grow on me.
post #38 of 48
You are going in the wrong direction. You want that deep V to emphasize the verticle. This does the opposite.
post #39 of 48
Quote:
Originally Posted by JakeLA View Post
Man, you could fit 3 wrists in those shirt cuffs And that watch is soooo stylin'. Melart Jewelers?
post #40 of 48
I think a four-button SB can work, but it would take work to make it work. We today are used to having the V of the lapels do most of the work in suggesting the masculine inverted triangle. If the V is very short, as with a four-button SB, something else has to take on that job. The way to do it is to have the coat made with strong waist suppression and probably also a clean, close chest. Something like John Steed here with his high-buttoning 3B. That pinched waist and strong shoulders look will counterbalance the mass of monochrome that the whole upper body presents with a four-button SB. Unfortunately, it also means the coat would probably have to be bespoke, unless you were unbelievably lucky and found some Edwardian piece that fit.

This explains why NBA players, despite their long torsos, still look a bit strange in 4-button SB coats: if they are lounge-coat length, they tend not to have enough waist suppression to draw the eye to the shoulders. So their torsos end up looking like massive rectangles.
post #41 of 48
This is a hybrid of a type of english sport coat. I forget the name of it, but now people would think it is costume. I have an old picture of a Flusser RTW one from 1997 at Saks, if I can find it, I'll upload it to explain what it is.
post #42 of 48
Thread Starter 
Quote:
Originally Posted by Testudo_Aubreii View Post
I think a four-button SB can work, but it would take work to make it work. We today are used to having the V of the lapels do most of the work in suggesting the masculine inverted triangle. If the V is very short, as with a four-button SB, something else has to take on that job. The way to do it is to have the coat made with strong waist suppression and probably also a clean, close chest. Something like John Steed here with his high-buttoning 3B. That pinched waist and strong shoulders look will counterbalance the mass of monochrome that the whole upper body presents with a four-button SB. Unfortunately, it also means the coat would probably have to be bespoke, unless you were unbelievably lucky and found some Edwardian piece that fit.

This explains why NBA players, despite their long torsos, still look a bit strange in 4-button SB coats: if they are lounge-coat length, they tend not to have enough waist suppression to draw the eye to the shoulders. So their torsos end up looking like massive rectangles.



Huh. That seems like a brilliant explanation to me. I was getting depressed because I was looking at another....regular looking suit when I really wanted something a bit different. Do you have any other suggestions/guidelines? I like that 3 button with the high gorge - I guess that's why I'm not adamantly against a 4 button (because I've seen 3 buttons that go way up).

What about a 4 roll 3?
post #43 of 48
I had a navy 4-button jacket with gold buttons tailored for cheap in Shanghai. I wear it as a novelty to hipster concerts paired with a ludicrous graphic t-shirt. I cannot imagine any serious implementation of 4 button.
post #44 of 48
Quote:
Originally Posted by FulfilledDeer View Post
Huh. That seems like a brilliant explanation to me. I was getting depressed because I was looking at another....regular looking suit when I really wanted something a bit different. Do you have any other suggestions/guidelines? I like that 3 button with the high gorge - I guess that's why I'm not adamantly against a 4 button (because I've seen 3 buttons that go way up).

What about a 4 roll 3?

Sorry, that's about all I can come up with. A true 4 roll 3, instead of a 4 roll 3.5, would lessen the vertical effect of all the buttons and the long jacket edge, to be sure. But I think what the members here dislike isn't so much the long-line-of-buttons effect. It's more the lack of any sizeable open V between the lapels, where this isn't counterbalanced by Steed's pinched waist and definite shoulders. This is why high-buttoning 3B suits, too, are often trashed on SF. There's a good thread on that, with DocHolliday standing up for (some) high 3Bs, like Steed's. In fact, I stole many of these ideas from him.

I guess it would depend on where the 4 roll 3 rolled to. If it rolled to where a moderate 3B has the top button, it would effectively be a moderate 3B with an extra button.
post #45 of 48
four button suits have style!!




.... like a cast iron pan full of smashed and seared assholes!!!!
New Posts  All Forums:Forum Nav:
  Return Home
  Back to Forum: Classic Menswear
Styleforum › Forums › Men's Style › Classic Menswear › Nice 4 Button Suit?