First pair of good shoes for the office: AE Delray?

Not my cup of tea. I'd go for a more classic 5th Avenues or Park Avenues, alternatively the Vernons are really nice. And finally, a different look, but the Strands are great.

The Delrays are nice shoes. Quality of AE is good and they will last long if cared for and not worn daily. They are derby shoes - hence a less formal shoe. If they are a good choice depends on your dress code at work: If it is suit and tie, I'd go for an oxford like the AE Park Avenue or Fifth Avenue, if it is business casual the Delrays are a good choice.

Regarding fit: That is something you gotta find out by trying the shoes in the appropriate size (length AND width). Nobody here can tell you since we don't know your feet.

+1. I would also go for the Fifth or Park Aves. Alternatively, you can go with the Strand if you want a little more kick in your step. P.S. I can get them for you at a great discount so PM me when you make a decision (see link in signature below)

To expand on the replies above, nothing wrong with the quality of Delrays, but keep in mind that they're split-toe bluchers. If your office is business casual and you never need to wear a suit, they're perfectly fine. If you're looking to get shoes to wear with a suit, the Fifth Avenue or Park Avenue would be great choices. Personally, I'd go with the Strands--they go with business casual, but they can also be dressed up with a sportcoat or a not super-formal suit. Also, not sure what you mean by wearing them a lot--you need to give your shoes at least every other day off, otherwise you'll wear them down quickly.

I have a pair of Delrays in the brown and I love them, I find them very comfortable and make my wide foot look not so wide. But everyone above it right about the formality, I would never wear them with a suit, but with chinos, jeans and odd pants most definitely.

Pretty sure allaboutshoes, who posted above, can get you a much better deal than that. PM him and check out his thread, it's legit and a great deal.

Look at the AE Parliament in saddle brown. Looks like the Strand, but has the orthotic and executive sole. I have this shoe and it is a very comfortable shoe. The 5 last on the Strand/Park Avenue/Fifth Avenue fits a bit snug on my feet. But the Parliament is great for me. I can wear it all day with no problems.

In the saddle brown, the Parliament can go from suit to sport coat to business casual very well.

Chris

Not sure where you are located but if you have a Nordstrom Last Chance check there, I routinely see delrays there for $40. Usually in good shape, just in need of a conditioning/polishing.

It has a rubber sole. Would not recommend wearing that with a suit.

I'm not a fan of the moc-toe of the Delray. If you want a blucher consider the AE Leeds. If you have a high instep it will be more comfortable than the Park Avenue, but is still acceptable to wear with a suit.

It has a rubber sole, but stacked leather heel. This is nothing like the Vibram soles you see on some shoes, including some AE shoes. The Parliament looks just like the Strand unless you look directly at the bottom of the sole. I wear all 3 of my Executive Collection AE's (with rubber Executive sole) with suits.

Also, OP said he has shoes for his suit and was looking for something more "laid back for the business casual look".

Chris