Pick one of these ties for my groomsmen?

My wedding's coming up in a few months; I've fought off the bride's/family's requests for matching tuxes and instructed my groomsmen to wear their own charcoal suits. I'll be supplying them with MOP cufflinks and white pocket squares from Kent Wang to complete the ensemble. I know how bleh matching things can be -- still, I'd like to show my future in-laws some respect of their request by supplying the groomsmen with some ties that complement the bridesmaids' dresses (attached). My only criteria are 1) avoiding that shiny satin prom look, and 2) giving them a quality tie that they'll be able to wear in the future. With that in mind, I'm considering the following: 1) Drakes Pink/White Pencil Stripe 2) CT Price of Wales Purple Tie 3) Les Copains Lilac Microstripe - Yoox only lets me add 1 to the cart, so this is probably a no-go. Would appreciate your opinions on these, or any other ties you think might look nice. Thanks in advance.

I like 2

2 gets my vote as well

I like no. 1 best.

All 3 look very nice, but if I had to pick, I'd go for nr. 2

Originally Posted by Decaffeinated

Click to expand...

My wedding's coming up in a few months; I've fought off the bride's/family's requests for matching tuxes and instructed my groomsmen to wear their own charcoal suits. I'll be supplying them with MOP cufflinks and white pocket squares from Kent Wang to complete the ensemble.

I know how bleh matching things can be -- still, I'd like to show my future in-laws some respect of their request by supplying the groomsmen with some ties that complement the bridesmaids' dresses (attached).

My only criteria are 1) avoiding that shiny satin prom look, and 2) giving them a quality tie that they'll be able to wear in the future. With that in mind, I'm considering the following:

1) Drakes Pink/White Pencil Stripe

2) CT Price of Wales Purple Tie

3) Les Copains Lilac Microstripe - Yoox only lets me add 1 to the cart, so this is probably a no-go.

Would appreciate your opinions on these, or any other ties you think might look nice. Thanks in advance.

of the 3 you have shown I would choose No 1, but to be honest I think this would be a lot better more contrast and not so insipid.

Drakes

Do not get married.

Originally Posted by deandbn

Click to expand...

of the 3 you have shown I would choose No 1, but to be honest I think this would be a lot better more contrast and not so insipid.

Drakes

+1

If not number one.

vote for #2

Have you looked at Kent Wang's stuff?

Originally Posted by SpooPoker

Click to expand...

Have you looked at Kent Wang's stuff?
Phrasing, Spoo. Phrasing.

Originally Posted by Threadbearer

Click to expand...

Phrasing, Spoo. Phrasing.

I could have asked him if he checked out any Wangs lately.

Originally Posted by SpooPoker

Click to expand...

I could have asked him if he checked out any Wangs lately.
"Have you looked at Kent's Wang lately? Good stuff. Definitely worth the money."

For serious, though:

Why pink or lilac with charcoal suits? If you were doing navy suits, I could understand the desire for pastels. But charcoal doesn't harmonize especially well with pinks and purples. A lot of folks out there will tell you otherwise, but they're wrong. I have yet to see a picture of a charcoal suit with pink or purple tie that wouldn't look remarkably better with a rich navy suit.

#2