Heres the thing, the combined knowledge in this thread alone is so vast. Most of us here have dealt with very high end and very low end clothing, and through experience we can tell quality basically by looks and styles.
I dont want to be the bearer of bad news but youre holding onto the idea that material trumps construction and the cut of the garment.
Lets just start with the styling, it has long collars , low gorge and lapels with an ugly droop and cut. It is very reminiscent of old 1990's dated jackets and blazers. I cant tell from photos but the padding on those look ugly and bulky.
For the other jacket, its a hard three button stance and that is also dated and not something that people wear now a days. You want a higher gorge, slightly wider lapels, and a lower button stance (but thats preference).
If you truly wanted to learn about clothing, but put some effort into learning trends and styles from all generations and you will quickly realize what style you like. If you like the vintage looks, go for it. But everyone here is giving you appropriate answers that youre looking for , but you're just shoving it back down their throats without taking it in.
Hope this clears it up a bit..