just came across this thread but have to say, as long as i've owned nice shoes, the first thing i do is take them to nick and have flush plates on the toes and plastic taps on the heels installed. i think i pay $42 for both? anyways, nick's not someone who is going to tell you what you want to hear. nick will tell you what your options are on a sliding scale and he's always been right, at least with me.
even a time i spilled beer on a pair of church's which caused the shoes to get raised spots. he told me the chances of being able to correct it were slim to none, but he'd try if i wanted. he tried and he fixed them perfectly. this continues my point that nick is a straight shooter.
i've actually had two new pair of alden's sitting in my closet for 4 weeks now, that i haven't even put on because i haven't had time to drop them at nick's. i'm taking them in tomorrow, actually, and look forward to great work as usual.