I have the Moore a 1/2 size smaller than the St. James, so it would be an unfair comparison in terms of fit.
G&G has slightly better leather, tighter waist. I think the sole treatment are a tie. All based on my uneducated observations.
Ah, yes. I recall that boot now.
If there is broad interest in a Bramhall in Chestnut pin grain on MH71 last standard width with Wensum or Oak soles, I would be in on the GMTO.
I would probably also go for a Chester, Hayes, Kent or Burnham too.
Chestnut Pin Grain
On this shoe
Great description, thanks for sharing.